1. Initial Setup and Definitions:
- Let τ(n) denote the number of positive integer divisors of n.
- Let σ(n) denote the sum of the positive integer divisors of n.
- Let φ(n) denote the number of positive integers less than or equal to n that are relatively prime to n.
- We need to prove that for any integers a,b>1, Brandon can make the calculator display b after a finite sequence of button presses starting from a.
2. Reduction to a Simpler Problem:
- Notice that repeatedly applying τ to any number n will eventually reduce it to 2. This is because τ(n) is always at least 2 for any n>1 and τ(2)=2.
- Therefore, it suffices to show that from 2, Brandon can reach any positive integer b>1.
3. Reaching Powers of 2:
- We need to show that Brandon can reach every power of 2.
- Observe that τ(2k)=k+1. Hence, by applying τ to 2k, we can reach k+1.
- Conversely, φ(2k)=2k−1. Thus, by applying φ to 2k, we can reach 2k−1.
- By iterating this process, we can reach arbitrarily large powers of 2.
4. Reaching Arbitrarily Large Numbers:
- To show that we can reach numbers with arbitrarily large ν2 (the exponent of 2 in the prime factorization), consider the effect of φ on a number n.
- Applying φ to a number n decreases its νp (exponent of any prime p) by at most 1.
- Repeatedly applying φ will eventually reduce νp to 0 for any prime p.
5. Contradiction Argument:
- Suppose for contradiction that the νp of any reachable number is bounded for any prime p.
- Consider the number m after repeatedly applying φ until it is of the form 2i3j, 2ip where p=3 is an odd prime, or 2i.
- The ν2 of m decreases by at most 1 each time φ is applied, and increases by some number l.
- If l=1 for two consecutive applications of φ, then m must have exactly one odd prime divisor p without multiplicity, which is 3(mod4) and not equal to 3.
- However, φ(m) would then be divisible by at least two distinct odd primes, contradicting the assumption that l=1 for two consecutive applications.
6. Reaching Arbitrarily Large Numbers:
- Since σ(n) generates arbitrarily large numbers, we can reach arbitrarily large numbers.
- For large enough reachable n, repeated applications of φ starting from n must result in a number of the form 2ipn for some prime pn>3.
- This implies that f(n)n (where f(n) is the largest prime divisor of n) is bounded above, leading to a contradiction.
7. Conclusion:
- Therefore, Brandon can reach any positive integer b>1 from any starting integer a>1 using a finite sequence of button presses.
■