Example 3 Write a quadratic equation with positive real solutions on the blackboard. Two people, A and B, change the coefficients of the equation according to the rules: A subtracts a real solution from the constant term and adds 1 to the coefficient of the linear term; B can choose to change the constant term to any real number or choose to add the larger real solution of the equation on the blackboard to the constant term while subtracting 1 from the coefficient of the linear term, but when the difference between the two real solutions of the equation on the blackboard does not exceed 1, B can only choose the former option. Whoever makes the equation have no real solutions or have non-positive solutions, A wins. Question: Does A have a winning strategy?
Problem 1266
Official solution
【Analysis】Answer: Player A has a winning strategy.
A's strategy is to subtract the smaller real root of the original equation from the constant term and add 1 to the coefficient of the linear term in each operation.
The following proof shows that under A's strategy, B will inevitably choose the first option after a finite number of rounds.
Let the two roots of the equation before A's operation be and , at this point, the coefficient of the linear term , then the equation can be expressed as
The new equation after A's operation is
At this point, the roots of the new equation are and , and the corresponding coefficient of the linear term is , meaning that the two roots of the new equation obtained after A's operation are simply the larger root of the original equation reduced by 1 while the smaller root remains unchanged, and the coefficient of the linear term is increased by 1.
If B chooses the second option next, let the two roots of the equation before B's operation be and , at this point, the coefficient of the linear term , then the equation can be expressed as
The new equation after B's operation is
At this point, the roots of the new equation are and , and the corresponding coefficient of the linear term is , meaning that after B's operation, the smaller root of the equation increases by 1 while the larger root remains unchanged, and the coefficient of the linear term returns to the coefficient of the linear term before A's operation in this round.
Thus, if B always chooses the second option, then the difference between the two roots of the equation will inevitably be no more than 1 after a finite number of rounds (even if the equation remains so after another operation by A). Therefore, in the next round, B can only choose the first option. At this point, the coefficient of the linear term is .
Thereafter, if A adopts the same strategy, B will still not be able to always choose the second option, so after a finite number of rounds, B will eventually choose the first option. At this point, the coefficient of the linear term is .
If the game continues without A winning, the coefficient of the linear term will inevitably become a non-negative real number at some point, at which point A will still win.
Therefore, under the aforementioned strategy, A will inevitably win.