Let n be a positive integer, and consider the matrix A\equal(aij)1≤i,j≤n where aij\equal1 if i\plusj is prime and aij\equal0 otherwise.
Prove that ∣detA∣\equalk2 for some integer k.
This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark
yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.
Official solution
To prove that ∣detA∣=k2 for some integer k, we will analyze the structure of the matrix A and use properties of determinants and permutations.
1. Matrix Definition and Structure: - The matrix A=(aij)1≤i,j≤n is defined such that aij=1 if i+j is prime, and aij=0 otherwise. - This means that A is a symmetric matrix because aij=aji.
2. Permutation and Sign Function: - Consider the set B of bijective maps from {1,3,…,2n−1} to {2,4,…,2n}. - For f,g∈B, define the permutation π(f,g)∈S2n such that: π(f,g)(i)={f(i)g−1(i)if i is odd,if i is even. - Define δ(f)=sgn(π(f,h)) for a fixed h∈B.
3. Properties of Permutations: - It can be checked that π(f,g)π(g,f)=Id and π(f,g)=π(f,h)π(h,h)π(h,g). - Therefore, sgn(π(f,g))=δ(f)δ(g)δ(h). - It is also straightforward to check that δ(h)=(−1)n.
4. **Determinant Calculation for Even n**: - Let X=(xi,j) be a 2n×2n matrix with xi,j=0 whenever i+j is even and at least 4. - For σ∈S2n, the product x1,σ(1)…x2n,σ(2n) vanishes unless {σ(1),σ(3),…,σ(2n−1)}={2,4,…,2n}, i.e., σ=π(f,g) for some f,g∈B. - Hence, detX=σ∈S2n∑(sgn(σ))x1,σ(1)…x2n,σ(2n)=f,g∈B∑sgn(π(f,g))x1,f(1)x3,f(3)…x2n−1,f(2n−1)xg(1),1xg(3),3…xg(2n−1),2n−1. - This simplifies to: detX=(−1)nf∈B∑δ(f)x1,f(1)x3,f(3)…x2n−1,f(2n−1)f∈B∑δ(f)xf(1),1xf(3),3…xf(2n−1),2n−1.
5. **Determinant Calculation for Odd n**: - Let X=(xi,j) be a 2n+1×2n+1 matrix with xi,j=0 whenever i+j is even and at least 4. - The product x1,σ(1)…x2n+1,σ(2n+1) vanishes unless σ(1)=1 and {σ(2),σ(4),…,σ(2n)}={3,5,…,2n+1}. - The determinant of X is x1,1 times the (1,1)-th minor, which is of the form considered in the preceding paragraph. - For a closed expression, set yi,j=xi−1,j−1 to obtain: detX=(−1)nx1,1f∈B∑δ(f)y1,f(1)y3,f(3)…y2n−1,f(2n−1)f∈B∑δ(f)yf(1),1yf(3),3…yf(2n−1),2n−1.
6. Conclusion: - If X is symmetric and x1,1=1, we obtain detX=±1×a square. - Therefore, ∣detA∣=k2 for some integer k.
■
The final answer is ∣detA∣=k2 for some integer k.
Source: NuminaMath-1.5,
licensed Apache-2.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added
by this site.