Prove that if is a natural number such that is prime then for some .
Problem 1360
Official solution
To prove that if is prime, then for some , we will proceed as follows:
1. **Initial Check for Small Values of **:
- If , then , which is prime. Thus, satisfies the condition.
2. **General Case for **:
- Assume is a prime number and .
- We can rewrite the expression as .
3. Divisibility by 7:
- Consider the expression . We can factorize it as:
- Notice that . Therefore:
- Since is divisible by 7 (as ), it follows that must be divisible by 7 if is not divisible by 7.
4. Divisibility by 3:
- For to be divisible by 7, must be divisible by 3. Let for some .
5. Prime Divisors and Order:
- Consider the number . This is a positive integer greater than 1.
- This fraction must have a prime divisor . We need to show that is not divisible by .
- If , then divides but not .
6. Contradiction and Conclusion:
- If , then , which is a contradiction since .
- Therefore, there exists a prime such that divides and .
- This implies divides , meaning . Hence, divides , leading to .
7. Final Contradiction:
- Since is odd (otherwise would be divisible by 3), and if has prime divisors other than 3, then , which is a contradiction.
Thus, the only possible values for are of the form .
The final answer is for some .