In how many ways every unit square of a x board can be colored in red or white such that number of red unit squares in any two rows are distinct and number of red squares in any two columns are distinct.
Problem 1252
Official solution
1. Lemma Proof:
We need to show that the distinct numbers of red squares in rows and columns must be either or .
- Suppose some is not contained in the rows (or columns). This implies that both and must be contained in the rows (or columns).
- Therefore, the distinct numbers of red squares for each column (or row), denoted as for , must satisfy , which gives us distinct numbers in total.
- This is a contradiction because we need distinct numbers. Hence, the distinct numbers must be either or .
2. Equivalence of Cases:
- The number of ways to color the board using is equal to the number of ways using .
- This is because we can consider white squares instead of red squares, effectively swapping the roles of red and white.
3. Counting the Ways:
- We denote as a possible way of coloring, where denotes the number of red squares in the -th row, and denotes the number of red squares in the -th column.
- We need to prove that there exists a unique way satisfying and for any distinct .
4. Existence Proof:
- Consider the original way where is red if .
- Rearrange the rows and columns so that the way satisfies .
- It is easy to check that the new way is as desired. When swapping, the number of blocks in rows and columns does not affect each other.
5. Uniqueness Proof:
- For , the solution is trivial.
- Assume it works for any . For the case , without loss of generality, let the first row's number be and the first column's number be .
- Remove these two lines, and we obtain the uniqueness for .
- Each line we remove, which is full of red squares, is also unique for any possible way. This completes the proof.
6. Final Calculation:
- The number of ways to arrange the rows is and the number of ways to arrange the columns is also .
- Therefore, the total number of ways is .
The final answer is