Olympiad Maths Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 165 of 400 #1165 of 2000

Problem 1165

National olympiad, first round
Geometry Difficulty 6.2 Prove it

(1) For any side bb of a convex polygon PP, construct a triangle with the largest area inside PP using bb as one of its sides. Prove: For each side of PP, the sum of the areas of the triangles obtained by the above method is at least twice the area of PP.

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.

Official solution

First, we prove a lemma.
Lemma: For each convex 2n2n-gon with area SS, the area of the triangles formed by its sides and vertices is not less than S2\frac{S}{2}.
Proof of the lemma: The main diagonal of a 2n2n-gon is a diagonal that divides the 2n2n-gon into two polygons, each containing the same side. For any side bb of the 2n2n-gon, b\triangle_{b} denotes the triangle ABPABP, where A,BA, B are the endpoints of bb, and PP is the intersection of the main diagonals AAAA' and BBBB'. We will prove that the union of the triangles b\triangle_{b} taken over all sides covers the entire polygon.

To this end, select any side ABAB, and consider the main diagonal AAAA' as a directed segment. Let XX be any point in the polygon that is not on any main diagonal, and assume without loss of generality that XX is to the left of the ray AAAA'. Consider the sequence of main diagonals AA,BB,CC,AA', BB', CC', \cdots, where A,B,C,A, B, C, \cdots are consecutive vertices to the right of AAAA'.

The nn-th term in this sequence is the diagonal AAA'A, and XX is to its right. Therefore, before AA', there exist two consecutive vertices K,LK, L in the sequence A,B,C,A, B, C, \cdots such that XX is to the left of KKKK' and to the right of LLLL'. This implies that XX is in the triangle l\triangle l', where l=KLl' = K'L'. A similar argument can be made for points XX to the right of AAAA' (points on the main diagonals can be ignored). Thus, the union of the triangles b\triangle_{b} covers the entire polygon.

Their total area is not less than SS, so we can find two opposite sides, such as b=ABb = AB and b=ABb' = A'B' (where AAAA' and BBBB' are main diagonals), such that [b]+[b]Sn[\triangle_{b}] + [\triangle_{b'}] \geq \frac{S}{n}, where [][\cdots] denotes the area of a region. Let AAAA' and BBBB' intersect at PP. Without loss of generality, assume PBPBPB \geq PB', then [ABA]=[ABP]+[PBA][ABP]+[PAB]=[b]+[b]Sn[ABA'] = [ABP] + [PBA'] \geq [ABP] + [PA'B'] = [\triangle_{b}] + [\triangle_{b'}] \geq \frac{S}{n}. The lemma is proved.

Now, assume the convex polygon PP has area SS and mm sides a1,a2,,ama_1, a_2, \cdots, a_m. Let SiS_i be the largest triangle in PP with side aia_i. If the conclusion does not hold, then
i=1mSiS<1. \sum_{i=1}^{m} \frac{S_i}{S} < 1.
Let nn be the common denominator of the mm fractions q1,q2,,qmq_1, q_2, \cdots, q_m. Let qi=kinq_i = \frac{k_i}{n}, then
ki=2n. \sum k_i = 2n.
Divide each side aia_i of PP into kik_i equal parts, resulting in a convex 2n2n-gon with area SS (some angles may be 180180^\circ). Apply the lemma to this 2n2n-gon. According to the lemma, there is a side bb and a vertex HH such that the triangle TT formed by bb and HH has area [T]Sn[T] \geq \frac{S}{n}. If bb is a part of the side aia_i of PP, then the triangle WW with base aia_i and the highest vertex HH has area
[W]=ki[T]kiSn=qiS>Si, [W] = k_i \cdot [T] \geq k_i \cdot \frac{S}{n} = q_i \cdot S > S_i,
which contradicts the definition of SiS_i. The proof is complete.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.