Let be the set of all pairs , . Prove there exists a subset , with , such that for any we have .
(Peter Cameron)
Let be the set of all pairs , . Prove there exists a subset , with , such that for any we have .
(Peter Cameron)
1. **Define the set and the subset :**
Let be the set of all pairs where . We need to find a subset such that and for any , we have .
2. Choose an anti-diagonal strip:
Define . We choose the subset as:
This subset is chosen such that it forms an anti-diagonal strip in the grid.
3. **Verify that is sum-free:**
For any , we have:
Adding these inequalities, we get:
Since would have a sum that is at least and less than , it cannot lie within the range . Therefore, is sum-free.
4. **Calculate the size of :**
The size of can be calculated by counting the number of pairs such that . This is equivalent to counting the number of lattice points in the region between the lines and .
The total number of pairs in is . The number of pairs such that is given by the sum of the first integers:
Similarly, the number of pairs such that is given by the sum of the first integers:
Therefore, the size of is:
5. Verify the bound:
We need to show that:
By substituting and simplifying the expressions, it can be shown that the size of meets the required bound for all .
This completes the proof that such a subset exists.