Let denote the set of all natural numbers. Show that there exists two nonempty subsets and of such that
[list=1]
[*]
[*] every number in can be expressed as the product of a number in and a number in ;
[*] each prime number is a divisor of some number in and also some number in ;
[*] one of the sets and has the following property: if the numbers in this set are written as , then for any given positive integer there exists such that .
[*] Each set has infinitely many composite numbers.
[/list]
Problem 1714
Official solution
To solve this problem, we need to construct two nonempty subsets and of that satisfy the given conditions. Let's go through each condition step-by-step.
1. **Condition 1: **
We need to ensure that the only common element between and is .
2. **Condition 2: Every number in can be expressed as the product of a number in and a number in **
This means for any , there exist and such that .
3. **Condition 3: Each prime number is a divisor of some number in and also some number in **
For any prime , there should be some and such that divides and divides .
4. **Condition 4: One of the sets and has the property that if the numbers in this set are written as , then for any given positive integer , there exists such that
This means that one of the sets has arbitrarily large gaps between consecutive elements.
5. Condition 5: Each set has infinitely many composite numbers**
Both and should contain infinitely many composite numbers.
Let's construct the sets and as follows:
- Let
- Let
Now, let's verify each condition:
1. **Condition 1: **
By construction, contains and other specific numbers, while contains and all natural numbers not in . Therefore, .
2. **Condition 2: Every number in can be expressed as the product of a number in and a number in **
For any , we can take and . Thus, .
3. **Condition 3: Each prime number is a divisor of some number in and also some number in **
- For , .
- For any odd prime , (by Fermat's Little Theorem), and .
4. **Condition 4: One of the sets and has the property that if the numbers in this set are written as , then for any given positive integer , there exists such that **
The set has this property because the numbers grow exponentially, so the gaps between consecutive elements increase exponentially.
5. Condition 5: Each set has infinitely many composite numbers
- For , we can take powers of (e.g., ).
- For , note that is composite for all .
Thus, all conditions are satisfied.
The final answer is and .