1. Restate the Problem in Terms of Hyperrectangles:
We are given arithmetic progressions P1,P2,…,Ps of integers such that:
- Each integer belongs to at least one progression.
- Each progression contains a number that does not belong to any other progression.
We need to prove that the number of progressions s is at least 1+∑i=1kαi(pi−1), where n=lcm(r1,r2,…,rs) and n=p1α1p2α2⋯pkαk.
2. Transform the Problem into a Geometric Setting:
Consider the numbers 0,1,…,n−1 as points in a hyperrectangle. Each point can be represented by coordinates in a space defined by the prime factors of n. Specifically, for each prime pi, we have αi intervals [0,pi−1].
3. Define the Bijection:
Each number x in the range 0 to n−1 can be uniquely represented by its residues modulo pi and their powers. This representation forms a bijection between the numbers and the points in the hyperrectangle.
4. Characterize the Progressions:
Each progression P with ratio r=p1b1p2b2⋯pkbk (where 0≤bi≤αi) can be seen as a subset of the hyperrectangle. The coordinates corresponding to the first bi intervals for each pi are fixed, while the remaining αi−bi coordinates are free.
5. Induction Hypothesis:
We will use induction on the sum ∑i=1kαi. For the base case where all αi=0, the statement is trivially true since s≥1.
6. Induction Step:
Assume the statement holds for any hyperrectangle with ∑i=1kαi′<∑i=1kαi. We need to prove it for ∑i=1kαi.
7. Divide the Hyperrectangle:
Choose an interval corresponding to p1 and divide the hyperrectangle into two smaller hyperrectangles:
- One using intervals [0,n1−1] and the rest unchanged.
- The other using intervals [0,n2],…,[0,nk] and a dummy first coordinate.
8. Covering the Sub-Hyperrectangles:
Each progression in the original hyperrectangle can be split into progressions covering the sub-hyperrectangles. Ensure that each sub-hyperrectangle is covered by progressions that satisfy the conditions.
9. Count the Progressions:
Let x1 be the number of progressions in the first sub-hyperrectangle that do not use the interval [0,n1−1], and x2 be those that do. Similarly, let x3 and x4 be the corresponding counts for the second sub-hyperrectangle. The total number of progressions is x1+x2+x3+x4−x5, where x5 accounts for double-counted progressions.
10. Apply Induction:
Use the induction hypothesis on the sub-hyperrectangles to show that:
x1+x2≥1+i∈S1∑ni′andx3+x4−x5≥1+i∈S2∖S1∑ni′
Combining these, we get:
x1+x2+x3+x4−x5≥1+i=1∑kni
11. Conclusion:
Therefore, the number of progressions s is at least 1+∑i=1kαi(pi−1).
■
The final answer is s≥1+i=1∑kαi(pi−1)