Show that the following equation has finitely many solutions (t,A,x,y,z) in positive integers t(1−A−2)(1−x−2)(1−y−2)(1−z−2)=(1+x−1)(1+y−1)(1+z−1)
This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark
yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.
Official solution
1. Rearrange the given equation: t(1−A−2)(1−x−2)(1−y−2)(1−z−2)=(1+x−1)(1+y−1)(1+z−1) Squaring both sides, we get: t(1−A−2)(1−x−2)(1−y−2)(1−z−2)=((1+x−1)(1+y−1)(1+z−1))2 Simplifying the right-hand side: ((1+x−1)(1+y−1)(1+z−1))2=(xx+1⋅yy+1⋅zz+1)2=x2y2z2(x+1)2(y+1)2(z+1)2 Therefore, the equation becomes: t(1−A−2)(1−x−2)(1−y−2)(1−z−2)=x2y2z2(x+1)2(y+1)2(z+1)2 Rearranging, we get: t(1−A−2)=(x−1)(y−1)(z−1)(x+1)(y+1)(z+1) Define: f(x,y,z)=(x−1)(y−1)(z−1)(x+1)(y+1)(z+1)
2. Assume for contradiction that there are infinitely many solutions: We need to show that t≤36.
3. **Bounding t:** - Note that A=1 does not yield any solutions, and neither does x=1, y=1, or z=1. - Therefore, 1−A−2≥43. - Since f(x,y,z) is decreasing in all of x,y,z, we have: f(x,y,z)≤f(2,2,2)=(2−1)3(2+1)3=27 - Combining these, we get: t≤4327=36
4. **Fix t=T:** Since t is bounded, there exists some T such that there are infinitely many solutions to the original equation with t=T.
5. **Finitely many solutions for fixed A:** Since f(x,y,z) is decreasing in each of x,y,z, there are only finitely many solutions for a fixed A. Consequently, there are solutions for infinitely many values of A.
6. **Bounding the median of x,y,z:** - Without loss of generality, assume x≥y≥z. - Suppose infinitely many solutions satisfy y≤N for some large integer N. - Then there exist y0,z0 such that there are infinitely many solutions with y=y0 and z=z0. - Since f(x,y0,z0) is decreasing in x and T(1−A−2) is increasing in A, there can be at most one solution, which is a contradiction.
7. **Bounding f(x,y,z):** - For all other solutions, taking N large enough, we can note that: f(x,y,z)≤f(N,N,z)≤(N−1N+1)2⋅z−1z+1<c for some fixed constant c<1.
8. Combining the results: - Adding back in the finitely many solutions that were disregarded, there is a constant C<1 such that f(x,y,z)<C for all solutions (T,A,x,y,z). - However, there must be solutions for infinitely many A, and: T(1−A−2)=f(x,y,z)<C fails for large enough A, which is a contradiction.
Thus, there can only be finitely many solutions to the equation, as desired.
Source: NuminaMath-1.5,
licensed Apache-2.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added
by this site.