Olympiad Maths Prep

Track / Stage 7 / 253 of 300 #1653 of 2000

Problem 1653

National olympiad second round; IMO P1/P4
Geometry Difficulty 7.6 Prove it

Let A0B0C0A_0B_0C_0 be a triangle. For a positive integer n1n \geq 1, we define AnA_n on the segment Bn1Cn1B_{n-1}C_{n-1} such that Bn1An:Cn1An=2:1B_{n-1}A_n:C_{n-1}A_n=2:1 and Bn,CnB_n, C_n are defined cyclically in a similar manner. Show that there exists an unique point PP that lies in the interior of all triangles AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n.

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.

Official solution

1. Define the sequence of triangles:
Let A0B0C0A_0B_0C_0 be the initial triangle. For each positive integer n1n \geq 1, define the points AnA_n, BnB_n, and CnC_n as follows:
- AnA_n is on the segment Bn1Cn1B_{n-1}C_{n-1} such that Bn1An:Cn1An=2:1B_{n-1}A_n : C_{n-1}A_n = 2:1.
- BnB_n is on the segment Cn1An1C_{n-1}A_{n-1} such that Cn1Bn:An1Bn=2:1C_{n-1}B_n : A_{n-1}B_n = 2:1.
- CnC_n is on the segment An1Bn1A_{n-1}B_{n-1} such that An1Cn:Bn1Cn=2:1A_{n-1}C_n : B_{n-1}C_n = 2:1.

2. Nested compact sets:
Each triangle AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n is a compact set, and the sequence of triangles is nested, i.e., An+1Bn+1Cn+1AnBnCnA_{n+1}B_{n+1}C_{n+1} \subseteq A_nB_nC_n for all nn. By the finite intersection property of nested compact sets, there exists at least one point PP that lies in the intersection of all these triangles.

3. Uniqueness of the intersection point:
We need to show that the intersection of all triangles AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n is a single point. Assume for contradiction that the intersection contains more than one point. Then there exist subsequences of AnA_n, BnB_n, and CnC_n (denoted again by AnA_n, BnB_n, and CnC_n for simplicity) that converge to distinct points AA, BB, and CC, respectively.

4. **Case 1: AA, BB, and CC are distinct:**
Without loss of generality, assume BAC60\angle BAC \leq 60^\circ. For sufficiently large nn, the points AnA_n, BnB_n, and CnC_n are close to AA, BB, and CC, respectively. Consider the next triangle An+1Bn+1Cn+1A_{n+1}B_{n+1}C_{n+1}. The side Bn+1Cn+1B_{n+1}C_{n+1} is far from AA, implying that AA is outside An+1Bn+1Cn+1\triangle A_{n+1}B_{n+1}C_{n+1}. This contradicts the assumption that AA is a limit point of the sequence AnA_n.

5. **Case 2: B=CAB = C \neq A:**
In this case, BnAnCn<60\angle B_nA_nC_n < 60^\circ (it tends to 0 as nn \to \infty). Applying the same argument as in Case 1, we find that AA cannot be a limit point of the sequence AnA_n, leading to a contradiction.

6. Conclusion of uniqueness:
Since both cases lead to contradictions, the points AnA_n, BnB_n, and CnC_n must converge to a common point PP. Therefore, there is a unique point PP that lies in the intersection of all triangles AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n.

7. Interior of the triangles:
Finally, we need to show that PP lies in the interior of all triangles AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n. Assume for contradiction that PP lies on some side, say AnBnA_nB_n, for some nn. Then PP would be outside An+2Bn+2Cn+2\triangle A_{n+2}B_{n+2}C_{n+2}, which contradicts the fact that PP is in the intersection of all triangles. Hence, PP must lie in the interior of all triangles AnBnCnA_nB_nC_n.

8. Generalization:
The proof remains valid if we only require that An+1A_{n+1}, Bn+1B_{n+1}, and Cn+1C_{n+1} are on the sides BnCnB_nC_n, AnCnA_nC_n, and AnBnA_nB_n, respectively, and not too close to the vertices AnA_n, BnB_n, CnC_n. Specifically, the distance from An+1A_{n+1} to both points BnB_n and CnC_n should be greater than εBnCn\varepsilon \cdot |B_nC_n| for some fixed ε>0\varepsilon > 0, and similarly for Bn+1B_{n+1} and Cn+1C_{n+1}.

\blacksquare

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.