Olympiad Maths Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 104 of 400 #1104 of 2000

Problem 1104

National olympiad, first round
Algebra Difficulty 6.2 Find the answer

Is there a point PP on the parabola pp with the equation y=x2y=x^{2} and a point QQ on the parabola qq with the equation y=2x27x/2+57/16y=2 x^{2}-7 x / 2+57 / 16 such that the segment PQP Q is perpendicular to both parabolas pp and qq? (By the angle between a parabola and a line intersecting it, we mean the angle between the tangent to the parabola at the intersection point and the line.)

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.

Official solution

I. Solution. Let's assume that the answer to the problem is affirmative, and the point P(t,t2)P\left(t, t^{2}\right) on the parabola pp and the point Q(u,2u27u/2+57/16)Q\left(u, 2 u^{2}-7 u / 2+57 / 16\right) on the parabola qq satisfy the condition. Then the tangent to pp at PP and the tangent to qq at QQ are parallel to each other.

!

Since the ordinate is a differentiable function of the abscissa for both curves, the tangent's slope is given by the derivative at the respective point, which is 2t2t for pp and PP, and 4u7/24u - 7/2 for qq and QQ, and these two are equal:

2t=4u7/2,t=2u7/4 2t = 4u - 7/2, \quad t = 2u - 7/4

On the other hand, the line PQPQ is perpendicular to both tangents, i.e., PQPQ is a common normal to both parabolas. The slope of the normal to qq at QQ is 1/(4u7/2)-1/(4u - 7/2), provided the denominator is non-zero, i.e., u7/8u \neq 7/8. Thus, the equation of the normal is:

y(2u272u+5716)=14u7/2(xu) y - \left(2u^2 - \frac{7}{2}u + \frac{57}{16}\right) = \frac{-1}{4u - 7/2}(x - u)

and this equation is satisfied by the coordinates of PP. Substituting the coordinates of PP in terms of uu using (1), we get an equation for uu:

(2u74)22u2+72u5716=14u7/2(u7/4)8u321u2+454u=8u(u2218u+4532)=8u(u158)(u34)=0 \begin{gathered} \left(2u - \frac{7}{4}\right)^2 - 2u^2 + \frac{7}{2}u - \frac{57}{16} = \frac{-1}{4u - 7/2}(u - 7/4) \\ 8u^3 - 21u^2 + \frac{45}{4}u = 8u\left(u^2 - \frac{21}{8}u + \frac{45}{32}\right) = 8u\left(u - \frac{15}{8}\right)\left(u - \frac{3}{4}\right) = 0 \end{gathered}

Thus, the appropriate values of uu, and then tt using (1), and the corresponding pairs of points P,QP, Q that satisfy the condition are as follows (arranged in columns):

u1=0u2=34u3=158t1=74t2=14t3=2P1(74;494)P2(14;116)P3(2;4)Q1(0;5716)Q2(34;3316)Q3(159;12932) \begin{array}{lll} u_1 = 0 & u_2 = \frac{3}{4} & u_3 = \frac{15}{8} \\ t_1 = -\frac{7}{4} & t_2 = -\frac{1}{4} & t_3 = 2 \\ P_1\left(-\frac{7}{4} ; \frac{49}{4}\right) & P_2\left(-\frac{1}{4} ; \frac{1}{16}\right) & P_3(2 ; 4) \\ Q_1\left(0 ; \frac{57}{16}\right) & Q_2\left(\frac{3}{4} ; \frac{33}{16}\right) & Q_3\left(\frac{15}{9} ; \frac{129}{32}\right) \end{array}

Remark. The precise determination of the pairs of points Pi,Qi(i=1,2,3)P_i, Q_i (i=1,2,3) is based on recognizing that u=0u=0 is a root of the cubic equation (3). If we had eliminated uu instead of tt, this fortunate situation would not have arisen. It is therefore useful to sometimes try such approaches.

II. Solution (outline). Any two parabolas, v1v_1 and v2v_2, are similar to each other (in shape), as they are determined by a single linear parameter, p1p_1 and p2p_2, respectively. By scaling v1v_1 by a factor of λ=p2/p1\lambda = p_2 / p_1 and appropriately translating it, we obtain v2v_2. In this transformation, the foci F1F_1 and F2F_2, and the vertices C1C_1 and C2C_2, correspond to each other in pairs. Furthermore, the image of any point A1A_1 on v1v_1 in v2v_2 is the point A2A_2 where the ray from F2F_2 that forms the same angle and direction as the angle C1F1A1C_1 F_1 A_1 intersects v2v_2.

If the axes of the two parabolas are parallel (and lie in the same plane), the tangent at any point A1A_1 on v1v_1 is parallel to the tangent at the corresponding point A2A_2 on v2v_2. In this case, v1v_1 and v2v_2 are in a central similarity position relative to each other—unless C1F1F2C2C_1 F_1 F_2 C_2 forms a parallelogram—the center of similarity is the intersection point HH of the lines F1F2F_1 F_2 and C1C2C_1 C_2. (In the special case, v1v_1 and v2v_2 can be translated into each other).

In our case, we are looking for a pair of points P,QP, Q on the parabolas pp and qq with parallel axes such that the tangents at these points are parallel. Therefore, PP and QQ are corresponding points in the similarity, as a parabola can have exactly one tangent parallel to any given direction. Thus, the line PQPQ passes through HH. Based on this, our plan is as follows: we calculate the coordinates of HH, write the equation of the normal nn to qq at the point QQ with abscissa uu, and then we get an equation for uu by substituting the coordinates of HH into the equation of nn.

Now, the given parabola pp has its vertex C1C_1 at the origin, and its parameter is p1=1/2p_1 = 1/2. Similarly, by appropriately rearranging the equation of qq:


\left(x - \frac{7}{8}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{2

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.