Serafine and Jamie are playing catch with special rules. They
start by standing
apart. One throws the ball to the other. If the ball is caught, both
players each take a
step away from each other. If the ball is not caught, the person who
missed the catch takes a step towards the other
player. When they stop playing catch, they are apart. Of the following,
which number of throws is not possible?
CEMC Gauss (Grade 8), 2026
Pick one
Solution
Suppose that when Serafine and Jamie stop playing catch, they
have a total of catches and misses.
Each catch increases the distance between them by , and
so catches increases the distance
between them by .
Each miss decreases the distance between them by , and so misses decreases the distance between
them by .
They begin apart and
when they stop they are apart, and so .
Simplifying this equation, we get or . Dividing each term by , we get .
Since the question asks which number of throws is not possible, then we
let the number of throws be , and
so .
With and , we get the following equivalent
equations and so .
If , then or , and so . However, is not an integer and so
throws is not possible.
We can confirm that when is equal
to , , , and , then the number of throws, , is equal to , , , and , respectively.
In each case, and so is also a positive integer.
Of the given possibilities,
throws is not possible.