Problem:
For , let be the largest odd divisor of , and let . Prove that , and determine for which equality holds. For example,
thus
Problem:
For , let be the largest odd divisor of , and let . Prove that , and determine for which equality holds. For example,
thus
Solution:
Inspecting a few values leads one to the correct guess that equality holds if and only if is a power of . The idea is to use induction by "doubling" to prove the result. When , we have as desired. Now suppose . If with , then
with equality if and only if is a power of , i.e., if and only if is a power of . If instead with , then
so strict inequality holds, as desired.