Let S be a family of n sets, each has size k, such that AΔB∈S whenever A,B∈S,A=B.
a) Is it possible that n=2023? If it is, find all possible values of k.
b) Is it possible that n=1023? If it is, find all possible values of k.
Notation: AΔB=(A∖B)∪(B∖A).
Solution
a. We show that n=2023 is impossible. Let S={S1,S2,…,S2023} and T={1,2,…,2023}. We call a non-empty set I⊆T as nice if every non-empty subset J⊆I satisfies Δj∈JSj=∅. Note that any set of size one is nice, let L be the largest nice subset of T. Due to the condition given in the problem, we find Δj∈JSj∈S for all non-empty subsets J⊆L. On the other hand, for non-empty subsets J1,J2⊆L, J1=J2, we have J1ΔJ2=∅, which implies that (Δj∈J1Sj)Δ(Δj∈J2Sj)=Δj∈J1ΔJ2Sj. As J1ΔJ2⊆L, we get Δj∈J1ΔJ2Sj=∅. Therefore, for every non-empty J⊆L, Δj∈JSj is a distinct element of S. Now, given i∈T, if Si=Δj∈JSj for every non-empty J⊆L, then we would have i∈/L and L∪{i} is also nice, which is impossible. Hence, S={Δj∈JSj:J⊆L,J=∅}, which implies that 2023=2∣L∣−1, a contradiction.
b. We show that n=1023 can happen, and the answer is all positive integers k satisfying 512∣k. Let us take A∈S and x∈A. Define X⊆S as x∈X⇔X∈X and S∖X=Y. For every X∈X∖{A}, we have x∈/AΔX, so we get AΔX∈Y. Similarly, for every Y∈Y, we have x∈AΔY, so we get AΔY∈X∖{A}. As a result, we find ∣X∖{A}∣=∣Y∣, which means ∣X∣=512 as ∣S∣=1023. In other words, any x∈⋃S∈SS lies on exactly 512 sets. Letting N=⋃S∈SS, we find 1023k=512N, which gives 512∣k.
Let k=512m for some m∈N, and let L={1,2,…,10}. Start with empty 10 sets {S1,S2,…,S10}, and then for every non-empty R⊆L, we put m different elements in (r∈R⋂Sr)∖r∈L∖R⋃Sr. Now, for every non-empty J⊆{1,2,…,10}, we have Δj∈JSj=R⊆L,∣R∩J∣ odd⋃LR. Moreover, there are exactly 512 subsets R⊆L satisfying ∣R∩J∣ odd, which means that ∣Δj∈JSj∣=512m. On the other hand, for non-empty J1=J2, we have (Δj∈J1Sj)Δ(Δj∈J2Sj)=Δj∈J1ΔJ2Sj as J1ΔJ2=∅. Since ∣Δj∈J1ΔJ2Sj∣=512m, it is non-empty, which shows that Δj∈J1ΔJ2Sj∈S. As a result, the set S={Δj∈JSj:J⊆L,J=∅} contains exactly 1023 sets of size 512m which satisfies the desired condition.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.