Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /57 of 63

, 2023

Combinatorics Difficulty 8.9 Shortlist Prove it Turkey

Let S\mathcal{S} be a family of nn sets, each has size kk, such that AΔBSA \Delta B \in \mathcal{S} whenever A,BS,ABA, B \in \mathcal{S}, A \neq B.

a) Is it possible that n=2023n = 2023? If it is, find all possible values of kk.

b) Is it possible that n=1023n = 1023? If it is, find all possible values of kk.

Notation: AΔB=(AB)(BA)A \Delta B = (A \setminus B) \cup (B \setminus A).

Solution

a. We show that n=2023n = 2023 is impossible. Let S={S1,S2,,S2023}\mathcal{S} = \{S_1, S_2, \ldots, S_{2023}\} and T={1,2,,2023}T = \{1, 2, \ldots, 2023\}. We call a non-empty set ITI \subseteq T as nice if every non-empty subset JIJ \subseteq I satisfies ΔjJSj\Delta_{j \in J} S_j \neq \emptyset. Note that any set of size one is nice, let LL be the largest nice subset of TT. Due to the condition given in the problem, we find ΔjJSjS\Delta_{j \in J} S_j \in \mathcal{S} for all non-empty subsets JLJ \subseteq L. On the other hand, for non-empty subsets J1,J2LJ_1, J_2 \subseteq L, J1J2J_1 \neq J_2, we have J1ΔJ2J_1 \Delta J_2 \neq \emptyset, which implies that
(ΔjJ1Sj)Δ(ΔjJ2Sj)=ΔjJ1ΔJ2Sj. (\Delta_{j \in J_1} S_j) \Delta (\Delta_{j \in J_2} S_j) = \Delta_{j \in J_1 \Delta J_2} S_j.
As J1ΔJ2LJ_1 \Delta J_2 \subseteq L, we get ΔjJ1ΔJ2Sj\Delta_{j \in J_1 \Delta J_2} S_j \neq \emptyset. Therefore, for every non-empty JLJ \subseteq L, ΔjJSj\Delta_{j \in J} S_j is a distinct element of S\mathcal{S}. Now, given iTi \in T, if SiΔjJSjS_i \neq \Delta_{j \in J} S_j for every non-empty JLJ \subseteq L, then we would have iLi \notin L and L{i}L \cup \{i\} is also nice, which is impossible. Hence, S={ΔjJSj:JL,J}\mathcal{S} = \{\Delta_{j \in J} S_j : J \subseteq L, J \neq \emptyset\}, which implies that 2023=2L12023 = 2^{|L|} - 1, a contradiction.

b. We show that n=1023n = 1023 can happen, and the answer is all positive integers kk satisfying 512k512 \mid k. Let us take ASA \in \mathcal{S} and xAx \in A. Define XSX \subseteq \mathcal{S} as xXXXx \in X \Leftrightarrow X \in X and SX=Y\mathcal{S} \setminus X = Y. For every XX{A}X \in X \setminus \{A\}, we have xAΔXx \notin A \Delta X, so we get AΔXYA \Delta X \in Y. Similarly, for every YYY \in Y, we have xAΔYx \in A \Delta Y, so we get AΔYX{A}A \Delta Y \in X \setminus \{A\}. As a result, we find X{A}=Y|X \setminus \{A\}| = |Y|, which means X=512|X| = 512 as S=1023|\mathcal{S}| = 1023. In other words, any xSSSx \in \bigcup_{S \in \mathcal{S}} S lies on exactly 512 sets. Letting N=SSSN = \bigcup_{S \in \mathcal{S}} S, we find 1023k=512N1023k = 512N, which gives 512k512 \mid k.

Let k=512mk = 512m for some mNm \in \mathbb{N}, and let L={1,2,,10}L = \{1, 2, \ldots, 10\}. Start with empty 10 sets {S1,S2,,S10}\{S_1, S_2, \ldots, S_{10}\}, and then for every non-empty RLR \subseteq L, we put mm different elements in
(rRSr)(rLRSr). \left(\bigcap_{r \in R} S_r\right) \setminus \left(\bigcup_{r \in L \setminus R} S_r\right).
Now, for every non-empty J{1,2,,10}J \subseteq \{1, 2, \ldots, 10\}, we have
ΔjJSj=RL, RJ oddLR. \Delta_{j \in J} S_j = \bigcup_{R \subseteq L,\ |R \cap J| \text{ odd}} L_R.
Moreover, there are exactly 512 subsets RLR \subseteq L satisfying RJ|R \cap J| odd, which means that ΔjJSj=512m|\Delta_{j \in J} S_j| = 512m. On the other hand, for non-empty J1J2J_1 \neq J_2, we have
(ΔjJ1Sj)Δ(ΔjJ2Sj)=ΔjJ1ΔJ2Sj (\Delta_{j \in J_1} S_j) \Delta (\Delta_{j \in J_2} S_j) = \Delta_{j \in J_1 \Delta J_2} S_j
as J1ΔJ2J_1 \Delta J_2 \neq \emptyset. Since ΔjJ1ΔJ2Sj=512m|\Delta_{j \in J_1 \Delta J_2} S_j| = 512m, it is non-empty, which shows that ΔjJ1ΔJ2SjS\Delta_{j \in J_1 \Delta J_2} S_j \in \mathcal{S}. As a result, the set
S={ΔjJSj:JL,J} \mathcal{S} = \{\Delta_{j \in J} S_j : J \subseteq L, J \neq \emptyset\}
contains exactly 1023 sets of size 512m512m which satisfies the desired condition.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.