Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /10 of 13

Number theory Difficulty 7.1 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Italy

Problem:

Consider the equation
x2001=yx. x^{2001} = y^{x}.

a. Determine all pairs (x,y)(x, y) of solutions in which xx is a prime number and yy is a positive integer.

b. Determine all pairs (x,y)(x, y) of solutions in which xx and yy are positive integers.

(Recall that 2001=323292001 = 3 \cdot 23 \cdot 29)

Solution

Solution:

a.
The required pairs are: (3,3667)\left(3, 3^{667}\right), (23,2387)\left(23, 23^{87}\right), (29,2969)\left(29, 29^{69}\right).

Indeed, let x=px = p be a prime number. Then from the equation it follows that in the factorization of yy there cannot be prime factors different from pp, hence y=pny = p^{n} for some nn. Substituting into the equation we thus have p2001=pnpp^{2001} = p^{n p}, from which 2001=np2001 = n p. It follows that pp must be a prime factor of 20012001 and n=2001/pn = 2001 / p. In this way we obtain the three pairs listed.

b.
The required pairs are
(1,1),(3,3667),(23,2387),(29,2969),(69,6929),(87,8723),(667,6673),(2001,2001)(1, 1), \left(3, 3^{667}\right), \left(23, 23^{87}\right), \left(29, 29^{69}\right), \left(69, 69^{29}\right), \left(87, 87^{23}\right), \left(667, 667^{3}\right), (2001, 2001).

Let pp be a prime that appears with exponent nn in the factorization of xx. Then from the equation we have that pp also appears in the factorization of yy, with an exponent that we denote by kk. We can therefore write x=pnax = p^{n} a, y=pkby = p^{k} b, where aa and bb are not divisible by pp. Substituting into the equation we find that p2001na2001=pkpnabpnap^{2001 n} \cdot a^{2001} = p^{k p^{n} a} \cdot b^{p^{n} a}. Equating the exponents relative to the prime pp, we thus have that 2001n=kapn2001 n = k a p^{n}, and hence pnp^{n} divides 2001n2001 n. We now have two cases.

- If pp does not divide 20012001, then pnp^{n} must divide nn, which is impossible since pn>np^{n} > n (since pn2n=(1+1)n=1n+n1n1+>np^{n} \geq 2^{n} = (1+1)^{n} = 1^{n} + n \cdot 1^{n-1} + \ldots > n).
- If pp is a factor of 20012001, then pn1p^{n-1} must divide nn, which is possible only for n=1n = 1. Indeed for n>1n > 1 we have pn12n1=(1+1)n1=1n+(n1)1n1+>np^{n-1} \geq 2^{n-1} = (1+1)^{n-1} = 1^{n} + (n-1) \cdot 1^{n-1} + \ldots > n.

We have thus shown that pp can only be 33, 2323, or 2929, and must appear with exponent 11 in the factorization of xx. Therefore xx is necessarily a divisor of 20012001.

On the other hand if dd is any divisor of 20012001, setting e=2001/de = 2001 / d one immediately obtains d2001=ded=(de)dd^{2001} = d^{e d} = \left(d^{e}\right)^{d}, so the pair (d,de)\left(d, d^{e}\right) is a solution of the equation.

Second solution

Let dd be the G.C.D. of xx and 20012001, and set x=dax = d a, 2001=de2001 = d e, so that a,ea, e are coprime. The equation simplifies to xe=yax^{e} = y^{a}, and hence we have x=zax = z^{a}, for some suitable zz, as can be seen by comparing the exponents of each prime factor of xx on the two sides of the equation.

Since xx and zz have the same prime factors and dd, being a divisor of 20012001, is a product of distinct primes, we also have z=dbz = d b, and hence da=(db)ad a = (d b)^{a}, that is a=bada1a = b^{a} d^{a-1}.

This implies that x=dx = d, and hence xx divides 20012001. Indeed if b>1b > 1, then ba>ab^{a} > a, while if b=1b = 1 and a,d>1a, d > 1, then da13a1>2a1ad^{a-1} \geq 3^{a-1} > 2^{a-1} \geq a.

(Recall that for every b2b \geq 2 and every integer a0a \geq 0 we have ba=(1+(b1))a=1+a(b1)+a+1b^{a} = (1 + (b-1))^{a} = 1 + a(b-1) + \ldots \geq a + 1).

On the other hand if dd is any divisor of 20012001, setting e=2001/de = 2001 / d one immediately obtains d2001=ded=(de)dd^{2001} = d^{e d} = \left(d^{e}\right)^{d}, so the pair (d,de)\left(d, d^{e}\right) is a solution of the equation.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from it; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.