Problem:
Consider the equation
a. Determine all pairs of solutions in which is a prime number and is a positive integer.
b. Determine all pairs of solutions in which and are positive integers.
(Recall that )
Problem:
Consider the equation
a. Determine all pairs of solutions in which is a prime number and is a positive integer.
b. Determine all pairs of solutions in which and are positive integers.
(Recall that )
Solution:
a.
The required pairs are: , , .
Indeed, let be a prime number. Then from the equation it follows that in the factorization of there cannot be prime factors different from , hence for some . Substituting into the equation we thus have , from which . It follows that must be a prime factor of and . In this way we obtain the three pairs listed.
b.
The required pairs are
.
Let be a prime that appears with exponent in the factorization of . Then from the equation we have that also appears in the factorization of , with an exponent that we denote by . We can therefore write , , where and are not divisible by . Substituting into the equation we find that . Equating the exponents relative to the prime , we thus have that , and hence divides . We now have two cases.
- If does not divide , then must divide , which is impossible since (since ).
- If is a factor of , then must divide , which is possible only for . Indeed for we have .
We have thus shown that can only be , , or , and must appear with exponent in the factorization of . Therefore is necessarily a divisor of .
On the other hand if is any divisor of , setting one immediately obtains , so the pair is a solution of the equation.
Second solution
Let be the G.C.D. of and , and set , , so that are coprime. The equation simplifies to , and hence we have , for some suitable , as can be seen by comparing the exponents of each prime factor of on the two sides of the equation.
Since and have the same prime factors and , being a divisor of , is a product of distinct primes, we also have , and hence , that is .
This implies that , and hence divides . Indeed if , then , while if and , then .
(Recall that for every and every integer we have ).
On the other hand if is any divisor of , setting one immediately obtains , so the pair is a solution of the equation.