The incircle C1 of triangle ABC touches the sides AB and AC at the points D and E, respectively. The incircle C2 of the triangle ADE touches the sides AB and AC at the points P and Q, and intersects the circle C1 at the points M and N. Prove that (a) the centre of the circle C2 lies on the circle C1; (b) the four points M,N,P,Q in appropriate order form a rectangle if and only if twice the radius of C1 is three times the radius of C2.
Solution
(a) Let I be the incentre of △ABC, and let J be the point of intersection of AI and C1. Then, the line AJ is the angle bisector of ∠DAE and the triangles ADI and AEI are congruent. In particular, ∠EIA=∠AID. We have ∠EIJ=2∠EDJ as both are subtended by the same arc. Also, ∠JID=2∠JDA (chord tangent angle). Thus ∠JDA=∠EDJ and DJ is the angle bisector of ∠EDA. So J is the incentre of △ADE, and it lies on C1.
(b) First Solution: Let r1 and r2 denote the radiuses of the circles C1 and C2. Let O be the midpoint of the segment MN and R the midpoint of the segment DE. PQ∥MN as they are both perpendicular on AI. Thus MNPQ is an isosceles trapezium with bases MN and PQ. It is a rectangle if and only if the lengths of these segments are equal. We calculate them in terms of r1 and r2.
In △OIM, we have ∣OM∣=∣MI∣sin(∠I), while from the cosine formula in △IMJ, cos(∠I)=2r122r12−r22=1−2r12r12, thus sin(∠I)=1−cos2(∠I)=2r12r24r12−r22and so ∣MN∣=2∣OM∣=r1r24r12−r22.
On the other hand, △JPQ and △IDE are similar as they have parallel sides. This implies ∣PQ∣/∣DE∣=r2/r1 and so ∣PQ∣=r1r2∣DE∣. We also have ∣DE∣/2=∣ER∣=∣QE∣ as both ER and EQ are tangent to C2. From the trapezium JQEI with right angles at Q and E we get ∣QE∣2=r12−(r1−r2)2=2r1r2−r22. Thus ∣PQ∣=r1r2∣DE∣=r12r2∣QE∣=r12r22r1r2−r22.
From the above, ∣MN∣=∣PQ∣⟺4r12−r22=22r1r2−r22⟺(2r1−r2)(2r1+r2)=4r2(2r1−r2)⟺2r1=3r2.
(b) Second Solution: Let r1 and r2 denote the radiuses of the circles C1 and C2. Let O be the midpoint of the segment MN, F the midpoint of the segment DE and R the midpoint of PQ. PQ∥MN as they are both perpendicular on AI. Thus MNPQ is an isosceles trapezium with bases MN and PQ. It is a rectangle if and only if the lengths of these segments are equal. Using Pythagoras, this is easily seen to be equivalent to ∣OJ∣=∣RJ∣.
The line through M and N is the radical axis of the two circles C1 and C2. The point O has therefore the same power with respect to these circles, i.e. ∣OJ∣⋅(2r1−∣OJ∣)=(r2−∣OJ∣)(r2+∣OJ∣),hence∣OJ∣=2r1r22.
As QR∥EF and QJ∥EI, the triangles RJQ and FIE are similar and so r2∣RJ∣=r1∣FI∣=r1r1−r2,hence∣RJ∣=r1r2(r1−r2).Finally we see ∣OJ∣=∣RJ∣⟺2r1r22=r1r2(r1−r2)⟺r2=2(r1−r2)⟺3r2=2r1.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.