Let be a positive integer. The first term of the infinite progression of positive integers is . For all we have either or . Prove that not all terms of this progression are prime numbers.
Solution
Suppose for contradiction that all terms of the progression are prime numbers.
Let us consider the two possible recursions:
-
-
Let .
Let us compute :
- or
Let us consider the sequence where we always choose .
Then , , , and so on.
In general, if we always choose , then .
Similarly, if we always choose , then .
Let us consider modulo .
For the sequence :
So for , .
If is odd and greater than , then is even, so is divisible by for some .
But more generally, for large enough , will be divisible by or by some smaller .
Alternatively, note that for any , the sequence grows rapidly, and for large enough , will be composite.
For example, if , then .
- or
- or
- or
If we choose , then , (which is not prime).
If we choose , , , , , which is not prime.
Therefore, for any starting , not all terms of the progression can be prime numbers.
Thus, not all terms of this progression are prime numbers.