a. Does there exist circles in the plane such that each circle passes through exactly centres of other circles?
b. Does there exist circles in the plane such that each circle passes through exactly centres of other circles?
a. Does there exist circles in the plane such that each circle passes through exactly centres of other circles?
b. Does there exist circles in the plane such that each circle passes through exactly centres of other circles?
a. No. Let the centres be , , , , . WLOG assume is the centre of . One of the following must occur.
* If is the centre of , then . So both and are equilateral triangles. Note that at least one of , must lie on the circle with centre . So lies on the circle with centre that passes through and . Similarly, lies on the circle with centre that passes through and . This is a contradiction since the two circles only meet at and .
* If is the centre of , then . So is an equilateral triangle. Thus, there must be points lying on the circle with centre that passes through and . In either case or , we get the same configuration as above and hence it is a contradiction.
b. Yes. Consider two equilateral triangles of side lengths having parallel sides and the same orientation such that each pair of corresponding vertices is at a distance apart. It is clear that each point has a distance to exactly three other points. Therefore, we can draw a circle with each point as centre and radius that passes through exactly other points.