Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /25 of 36

Geometry Difficulty 7.0 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Italy

Problem:

Fix the point CC on a circle centred at OO with diameter ABA B, with CC distinct from both AA and BB. Now let DD vary among all points of the arc ABA B not containing CC that are distinct from both AA and BB. Given DD, let EE be the point on the segment CDC D such that the lines BEB E and CDC D are perpendicular.
Prove that the product CEEDC E \cdot E D attains its maximum, as DD varies, precisely when B,OB, O, E,DE, D all lie on a circle.

Solution

Solution:

With reference to the figure on the left, let us denote by θ\theta the measure of the angle BCD\angle B C D.

Figure 1

The solution of the problem can be broken down into the following six steps.

- The points B,O,E,DB, O, E, D lie on a common circle if and only if DD is the midpoint of the arc ABA B on which it lies.
Indeed, it suffices to observe that the four points lie on a common circle if and only if DOB=DEB\angle D O B=\angle D E B. Moreover, DEB=90\angle D E B=90^\circ by construction, so the four points lie on a common circle if and only if DOB=90\angle D O B=90^\circ. This last equality holds if and only if the radius ODO D is perpendicular to the diameter ABA B, which is true if and only if DD is the midpoint of the arc ABA B.

- The point DD is the midpoint of the arc ABA B on which it lies if and only if θ=45\theta=45^\circ.
Indeed, it suffices to observe that the two angles ACD\angle A C D and DCB\angle D C B both have measure θ\theta, since they subtend the arcs ADA D and DBD B which have the same length, and the sum of the two angles equals ACB\angle A C B, which is a right angle because ABA B is a diameter.

- The point EE belongs to the semicircle with diameter CBC B lying on the same side of the line BCB C as AA.
Indeed, it suffices to observe that the point EE, by construction, sees the segment CBC B under an angle of 9090^\circ (and lies on the same side of the line BCB C as AA).

- Maximizing the product CEEDC E \cdot E D is equivalent to minimizing the distance from EE to OO.
Indeed, we claim that the product CEEDC E \cdot E D equals R2OE2R^2-O E^2, where RR is the length OAO A of the radius of the circle circumscribed about the triangle ABCA B C. This can be deduced by applying the intersecting chords theorem to the chord CDC D and the chord passing through OO and EE, divided by EE into segments of length R+OER+O E and ROER-O E. In other words, the product CEEDC E \cdot E D is by definition the power of the point EE with respect to the initial circle, and the power of any point EE interior to a circle of radius RR and centre OO equals R2OE2R^2-O E^2.

- Let us denote by OO' the midpoint of the segment BCB C, which as already seen is also the centre of a semicircle on which EE lies. The point of this semicircle closest to OO is obtained by intersecting the semicircle with the line OOO O'.
Indeed, with reference to the figure on the right, let us denote by EE this intersection, and by EE' any other point of the semicircle. Then from the triangle inequality (in every triangle one side is less than the sum of the other two) we deduce that
OO+OE=OE=OE<OO+OE O' O+O E=O' E=O' E'<O' O+O E'
from which, simplifying OOO' O, we conclude that OE<OEO E<O E', as required.

- The point EE coincides with the point previously defined, and hence maximizes the product CEEDC E \cdot E D, if and only if θ=45\theta=45^\circ.
Indeed, from the previous construction it follows that the triangle EOCE O' C is a right isosceles triangle with the right angle at OO'.

Alternative solution

As in the first two points of the previous solution, we obtain that the points B,O,E,DB, O, E, D lie on a common circle if and only if θ=45\theta=45^\circ.
Now we show in an alternative way that EE maximizes the product CEEDC E \cdot E D if and only if θ=45\theta=45^\circ.
First, we observe that in the right triangle BECB E C the relation CE=CBcosθC E=C B \cdot \cos \theta holds. Next, we observe that CDB=CAB\angle C D B=\angle C A B, since they subtend the same chord CBC B. Consequently, denoting by α\alpha the common measure of these angles, in the right triangle BDEB D E the relation ED=BDcosαE D=B D \cdot \cos \alpha holds. Finally, from the law of sines we know that DB=2RsinθD B=2 R \cdot \sin \theta, where RR is the radius of the initial circle.

Combining these three equalities, and applying the double-angle formula for the sine, we deduce that
CEED=(CBcosθ)(2Rsinθcosα)=CBRcosαsin(2θ). C E \cdot E D=(C B \cdot \cos \theta) \cdot(2 R \cdot \sin \theta \cdot \cos \alpha)=C B \cdot R \cdot \cos \alpha \cdot \sin (2 \theta) .
Since CB,RC B, R and α\alpha are fixed, it is clear that the product is maximal when 2θ=902 \theta=90^\circ, that is, θ=45\theta=45^\circ.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from en; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.