Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / China Girls' Mathematical Olympiad /31 of 51

China Girls' Mathematical Olympiad

Number theory Difficulty 6.4 National Olympiad Prove it China

Let pp be a prime number greater than 33. Prove that there exist integers a1,a2,…,ata_1, a_2, \dots, a_t that satisfy the following conditions:

a.
−p2<a1<a2<⋯<at≤p2, -\frac{p}{2} < a_1 < a_2 < \cdots < a_t \le \frac{p}{2},

b.
p−a1∣a1∣⋅p−a2∣a2∣⋅⋯⋅p−at∣at∣=3m, \frac{p-a_1}{|a_1|} \cdot \frac{p-a_2}{|a_2|} \cdot \cdots \cdot \frac{p-a_t}{|a_t|} = 3^m,
where mm is a positive integer.

Solution

Proof By the Division Algorithm, there exist unique integers qq and rr such that p=3q+rp = 3q + r, where 0<r<30 < r < 3.
Taking b0=rb_0 = r, then
p−b0∣b0∣=3c0⋅b1∗∣b0∣, where 3∤b1∗ and 0<b1∗<p2. \frac{p-b_0}{|b_0|} = \frac{3^{c_0} \cdot b_1^*}{|b_0|}, \text{ where } 3 \nmid b_1^* \text{ and } 0 < b_1^* < \frac{p}{2}.
Taking b1=±b1∗b_1 = \pm b_1^* such that b1≡p(mod3)b_1 \equiv p \pmod{3}, then
p−b1∣b1∣=3c1⋅b2∗b1∗, where 3∤b2∗ and 0<b2∗<p2. \frac{p-b_1}{|b_1|} = \frac{3^{c_1} \cdot b_2^*}{b_1^*}, \text{ where } 3 \nmid b_2^* \text{ and } 0 < b_2^* < \frac{p}{2}.
Taking b2=±b2∗b_2 = \pm b_2^* such that b2≡p(mod3)b_2 \equiv p \pmod{3}, then
p−b2∣b2∣=3c2⋅b3∗b2∗, where 3∤b3∗ and 0<b3∗<p2. \frac{p-b_2}{|b_2|} = \frac{3^{c_2} \cdot b_3^*}{b_2^*}, \text{ where } 3 \nmid b_3^* \text{ and } 0 < b_3^* < \frac{p}{2}.
Repeating this process, we get b0,b1,…,bpb_0, b_1, \dots, b_p.
Since these p+1p+1 integers are in the interval (−p2,p2)(-\frac{p}{2}, \frac{p}{2}), a certain integer occurs twice. Suppose bi=bjb_i = b_j, i<ji < j, and bib_i, bi+1b_{i+1}, ..., bj−1b_{j-1} are distinct. So,
p−bi∣bi∣⋅p−bi+1∣bi+1∣⋯p−bj−1∣bj−1∣=3ci⋅bi+1∗bi∗⋅3ci+1⋅bi+2∗bi+1∗⋯3cj−1⋅bj∗bj−1∗. \frac{p-b_i}{|b_i|} \cdot \frac{p-b_{i+1}}{|b_{i+1}|} \cdots \frac{p-b_{j-1}}{|b_{j-1}|} = \frac{3^{c_i} \cdot b_{i+1}^*}{b_i^*} \cdot \frac{3^{c_{i+1}} \cdot b_{i+2}^*}{b_{i+1}^*} \cdots \frac{3^{c_{j-1}} \cdot b_j^*}{b_{j-1}^*}.
Since bi=bjb_i = b_j, then bi∗=bj∗b_i^* = b_j^*. So the above expression equals to
3ci+ci+1+⋯+cj−1=3n,n>0. 3^{c_i+c_{i+1}+\cdots+c_{j-1}} = 3^n, \quad n > 0.
Put bi,bi+1,…,bj−1b_i, b_{i+1}, \dots, b_{j-1} in ascending order, as desired.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.