Problem:
Prove that when three circles share the same chord , every line through different from determines the same ratio , where is an arbitrary point different from on the first circle while and are the points where intersects the other two circles (labelled so that is between and ).
CMO, 2003
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
Solution:
Let be a line through different from and join to and as in the above diagram. No matter how is chosen, the angles and always subtend the chord . For this reason the angles in the triangles and are the same for all such . Thus the ratio remains constant by similar triangles.
Note that this is true no matter how and lie in relation to . Suppose and all lie on the same side of (as in the diagram) and that and . Then and . Now suppose is chosen so that is now on the opposite side of from and . Now since is on the other side of the chord , but it is still the case that and all other angles in the two pertinent triangles remain unchanged. If is chosen so that is identical with , then is tangent to the first circle and it is still the case that . All other cases can be checked in a similar manner.
Solution 2
Solution:
Let be the perpendicular bisector of and let be the centres of the three circles. Since is a chord common to all three circles, all lie on . Let be a line through different from and suppose that all lie on the same side of , as in the above diagram. Let perpendiculars from meet at , respectively. Since a line through the centre of a circle bisects any chord,
Now
Therefore . But , so . Since the centres of the circles are fixed, the ratio does not depend on the choice of .
If do not all lie on the same side of , we can obtain the same result with a similar proof. For instance, if and are opposite sides of , then we will have , but since in this case , it is still the case that and result still follows, etc.