Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /10 of 10

Combinatorics Difficulty 9.1 IMO level Prove it Netherlands

At a fish market there are 10 stalls, each selling the same 10 kinds of fish. Each fish was caught in either the North Sea or the Mediterranean Sea, and each stall has, for each kind of fish, only fish of one origin. A number, say kk, of customers buy exactly one fish from each stall, in such a way that they obtain exactly one of each kind of fish. Moreover, for each pair of customers, there is a kind of fish of which the customers have fish of different origin. Consider all possible ways to supply the stalls according to the rules above.
What is the largest possible value of kk?

Solution

The largest possible value of kk is 210102^{10} - 10. First note that there are 2102^{10} possible combinations for the origins per kind of fish. We show that there are always at least 10 exceptions (combinations that cannot be obtained by a customer), and that there is a way to supply the stalls for which there are exactly 10 exceptions.

Let us number both the stalls and the kinds of fish from 1 up to 10. For stall ii, define the sequence ai{M,N}10a_i \in \{M, N\}^{10} as the sequence of origins of the 10 kinds of fish in this stall. Let cic_i be the complement of aia_i, i.e. the sequence obtained from aia_i by replacing all MM's with NN's and vice versa. As every customer has bought a fish from stall ii, no customer can have cic_i as his sequence of fish origins. If all cic_i (1i101 \le i \le 10) are distinct, then we have 10 exceptions.

Otherwise, two of the stalls, say ii and jj, sell each kind of fish from the same origin, i.e. ai=aja_i = a_j, and therefore also ci=cjc_i = c_j. Define the sequences dkd_k with 1k101 \le k \le 10 by changing in cic_i the origin of kind kk of fish. These are the sequences which have exactly one origin in common with aia_i. If a customer would have had sequence dkd_k, then this customer therefore could only have bought a fish from one of stalls ii or jj, but not both, contradicting the given that every customer bought exactly one fish from every stall. Therefore also in this case, there are at least 10 exceptions.

We now construct a market in which it is possible to buy 210102^{10} - 10 possible combinations of fish origins as in the problem. Suppose that stall ii sells fish from the North Sea, unless the fish is of kind ii (in which case the fish is from the Mediterranean Sea). Let b{M,N}10b \in \{M, N\}^{10} be a sequence of origins in which the number of NN's is not exactly 1. We show that we can buy 10 fish from 10 stalls in such a way that bb is the sequence of origins. Let AA be the set of indices ii for which bi=Mb_i = M, and BB be the set of indices ii for which bi=Nb_i = N. For iAi \in A, buy a fish of kind ii from stall ii, so that we get a fish from the Mediterranean Sea. If BB is empty, then we are done. If not, then BB has at least two elements. Write B={i1,,in}{1,,10}B = \{i_1, \dots, i_n\} \subset \{1, \dots, 10\}. For ikBi_k \in B, buy fish of kind iki_k from stall ik+1i_{k+1}, considering the indices modulo nn. Since n1n \ge 1, we have ik+1iki_{k+1} \ne i_k, so this fish is from the North Sea, as required. \square

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.