Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / EGMO /7 of 22

EGMO

Geometry Difficulty 7.7 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it European Girls' Mathematical Olympiad (EGMO)

Problem:

Let ABCABC be an acute triangle. Points BB, DD, EE, and CC lie on a line in this order and satisfy BD=DE=ECBD = DE = EC. Let MM and NN be the midpoints of ADAD and AEAE, respectively. Let HH be the orthocentre of triangle ADEADE. Let PP and QQ be points on lines BMBM and CNCN, respectively, such that DD, HH, MM, and PP are concyclic and EE, HH, NN, and QQ are concyclic. Prove that PP, QQ, NN, and MM are concyclic.

The orthocentre of a triangle is the point of intersection of its altitudes.

Solutions — 6

Solution 1

Solution:

Denote by B′B' and C′C' the reflections of BB and CC in MM and NN, respectively. Points C′C', AA, B′B' are clearly collinear and DEB′ADEB'A is a parallelogram. Since EH⊥ADEH \perp AD, we have EH⊥EB′EH \perp EB'. Also HA⊥AB′HA \perp AB', so points H,E,B′,AH, E, B', A are concyclic. This gives

∠C′QH=∠NQH=∠NEH=∠AEH=∠AB′H=∠C′B′H, \angle C'QH = \angle NQH = \angle NEH = \angle AEH = \angle AB'H = \angle C'B'H,
and so points C′C', B′B', QQ, HH are concyclic. Analogously points C′C', B′B', PP, HH are concyclic, and so all points B′B', C′C', PP, QQ, HH are. Now we have

∠NMB′=∠AB′M=∠C′B′P=∠C′QP=∠NQP, \angle NMB' = \angle AB'M = \angle C'B'P = \angle C'QP = \angle NQP,
which proves that P,Q,N,MP, Q, N, M are also concyclic.

Figure 1

Introduce points B′B', C′C' as above. Also define A′=B′E∩C′DA' = B'E \cap C'D, so that EADA′EA DA' is a parallelogram and ADEADE is the medial triangle of A′B′C′A'B'C'. It that follows that the orthocentre HH of ADEADE is the circumcentre of A′B′C′A'B'C', and in particular

∠C′B′H=90∘−∠B′A′C′=90∘−∠DAE=∠AEH=∠NEH=∠NQH=∠C′QH. \angle C'B'H = 90^{\circ} - \angle B'A'C' = 90^{\circ} - \angle DAE = \angle AEH = \angle NEH = \angle NQH = \angle C'QH.
So again we have that C′C', B′B', QQ, HH are concyclic and conclude as in Solution 1.

Solution 2

Solution:

Let XX be the second intersection of (DHM)(DHM) and (EHN)(EHN) and let O′O' be the circumcentre of (AMN)(AMN). Note that ∠MXN=∠MDH+∠NEH=180∘−2∠DAE\angle MXN = \angle MDH + \angle NEH = 180^{\circ} - 2\angle DAE and since ∠MO′N=2∠DAE\angle MO'N = 2\angle DAE we have that X,M,O′,NX, M, O', N is cyclic and since ∠MXH=∠NXH\angle MXH = \angle NXH it means that HXHX is the angle bisector of ∠MXN\angle MXN but since O′M=O′NO'M = O'N it means that H,X,O′H, X, O' are collinear. Let BMBM and CNCN intersect at TT and let KK and LL be the midpoints of MNMN and BCBC. Note that LL is also the midpoint of DEDE. Since MNMN is parallel to BCBC it means that TT, KK, and LL are collinear, but since AA, KK, and LL are collinear we get that AA, TT, KK, and LL are collinear. Now, TLTK=BCMN=6\frac{TL}{TK} = \frac{BC}{MN} = 6. Since KL=KAKL = KA it means that ATTK=TL−2TKTK=4\frac{AT}{TK} = \frac{TL - 2TK}{TK} = 4 so by the lemma below, TT lies on HO′HO'. Since HO′HO' is the radical axis of (DHM)(DHM) and (EHN)(EHN) we finish the problem using the Radical Axes Theorem (TM⋅TP=TN⋅TQ)(TM \cdot TP = TN \cdot TQ).

Lemma. Let A′A' be the reflection of AA around the orthocentre HH of △ABC\triangle ABC and OO and MM be the circumcentre of △ABC\triangle ABC and the midpoint of BCBC, respectively. Let TT be the intersection of A′OA'O and AMAM. Then ATTM=4\frac{AT}{TM} = 4.

Proof. Since OM∥AA′OM \parallel AA' we have ATTM=AA′OM=2AHOM=4OMOM=4\frac{AT}{TM} = \frac{AA'}{OM} = \frac{2AH}{OM} = \frac{4OM}{OM} = 4. We used here that AH=2OMAH = 2OM. □\square

Figure 2

As in solution 2, we will prove that O′O' is both on line HTHT and the radical axis of the circles, hence TT is on the radical axis, from which we conclude the required concyclicity. We present alternative proofs of both facts, discovered by contestants.

Let M1M_{1}, N1N_{1} be the midpoints of AMAM, ANAN, respectively, so that AM1:M1D=AN1:N1E=1:3AM_{1}:M_{1}D = AN_{1}:N_{1}E = 1:3. It is easy to verify (e.g. by applying the theorems of Ceva or Menelaus, or by computing in barycentric coordinates as in Solution 3) that TT lies on EM1EM_{1} and DN1DN_{1}. Note that M1N1∥DEM_{1}N_{1} \parallel DE, and also M1O′∥HEM_{1}O' \parallel HE as both are perpendicular to AMDAMD, and similarly N1O′∥HDN_{1}O' \parallel HD. It follows that DEHDEH and N1M1O′N_{1}M_{1}O' are homothetically similar triangles, and the center of their (negative) homothety is T=DN1∩EM1T = DN_{1} \cap EM_{1}. Therefore TT also lies on HO′HO', as claimed. (We also have that the homothety is by factor M1N1ED=−14\frac{M_{1}N_{1}}{ED} = -\frac{1}{4}.)

Now, let M2M_{2}, N2N_{2} be the second intersection points of O′MO'M, O′NO'N with the circumcircles of HMDHMD, HNEHNE, respectively. To prove that O′O' is on the radical axis, it suffices to show that O′M⋅O′M2=O′N⋅O′N2O'M \cdot O'M_{2} = O'N \cdot O'N_{2}. But by definition of O′O' we have O′M=O′NO'M = O'N, so we must show O′M2=O′N2O'M_{2} = O'N_{2}, which is equivalent to M2N2∥MNM_{2}N_{2} \parallel MN. Angle chasing in circle MM2DHMM_{2}DH gives

∠OM2H=∠MM2H=∠MDH=∠ADH=90∘−∠EAD=90∘−∠NAM=∠O′MN, \angle OM_{2}H = \angle MM_{2}H = \angle MDH = \angle ADH = 90^{\circ} - \angle EAD = 90^{\circ} - \angle NAM = \angle O'MN,
from which it follows that M2H∥MNM_{2}H \parallel MN. Similarly, we have N2H∥MNN_{2}H \parallel MN, and the two facts together imply that M2,H,N2M_{2}, H, N_{2} are collinear and the line through them is parallel to MNMN, as claimed. □\square

Figure 3

Solution 3

Solution:

We compute using linear combinations with respect to ADEADE. We have B=2D−EB = 2D - E, C=2E−DC = 2E - D, M=A+D2M = \frac{A + D}{2}, and N=A+E2N = \frac{A + E}{2}, from which we immediately obtain that the intersection T=BM∩CNT = BM \cap CN is T=3A+D+E5=6M−B5=6N−C5T = \frac{3A + D + E}{5} = \frac{6M - B}{5} = \frac{6N - C}{5}. As in solution 2, we reduce to showing that TT is on the radical axis of HDMHDM and HENHEN, whence TM⋅TP=TN⋅TQTM \cdot TP = TN \cdot TQ proves the concyclicity of P,Q,N,MP, Q, N, M.

Synthetic finish, similar to Solution 2. Let OO be the circumcentre of ADEADE and O′=A+O2O' = \frac{A + O}{2} be the circumcentre of AMNAMN. As in Solution 2, we have that O′O' is on the desired radical axis, so it is enough to show T∈O′HT \in O'H. Let G=A+D+E3G = \frac{A + D + E}{3} be the barycentre of ADEADE. By properties of the Euler line, we also have G=H+2O3G = \frac{H + 2O}{3}. Now using our known identities we find

T=3A+D+E5=2A+3G5=2A+H+2O5=H+4O′5 T = \frac{3A + D + E}{5} = \frac{2A + 3G}{5} = \frac{2A + H + 2O}{5} = \frac{H + 4O'}{5}
and in particular T∈HO′T \in HO', as we wanted to show.

Computational finish. Let f(T)f(T) be the power difference at TT w.r.t. DHMDHM and HENHEN. We compute f(A)f(A) and f(L)f(L) where L=D+E2L = \frac{D + E}{2}. Since T=3A+2L5T = \frac{3A + 2L}{5}, it is enough to show that 3P(A)+2P(L)=03P(A) + 2P(L) = 0. In the following all lengths are directed. We compute trigonometrically: Let α,β,γ\alpha, \beta, \gamma be the angles of ADEADE and assume the diameter of its circumcircle is 11. We have

f(A)=AD2−AE22=sin⁡2(γ)−sin⁡2(β)2. f(A) = \frac{AD^{2} - AE^{2}}{2} = \frac{\sin^{2}(\gamma) - \sin^{2}(\beta)}{2}.
To compute P(L)P(L), let D′,E′D', E' be the second intersection points of HMD,HNEHMD, HNE with DEDE, and let M′,N′,FM', N', F be the feet of the perpendiculars from HH to AD,AE,DEAD, AE, DE, respectively. Note that DM′=sin⁡αcos⁡βDM' = \sin \alpha \cos \beta, thus

M′M=DM−DM′=sin⁡(α+β)2−sin⁡αcos⁡β=sin⁡(β−α)2. M'M = DM - DM' = \frac{\sin(\alpha + \beta)}{2} - \sin \alpha \cos \beta = \frac{\sin(\beta - \alpha)}{2}.
We also have HM′=cos⁡αcos⁡βHM' = \cos \alpha \cos \beta, HF=cos⁡βcos⁡γHF = \cos \beta \cos \gamma, and HM′M∼HFD′HM'M \sim HFD', therefore

FD′=HFHM′M′M=cos⁡γsin⁡(β−α)cos⁡α FD' = \frac{HF}{HM'} M'M = \frac{\cos \gamma \sin(\beta - \alpha)}{\cos \alpha}
and similarly
E′F=cos⁡βsin⁡(γ−α)cos⁡α. E'F = \frac{\cos \beta \sin(\gamma - \alpha)}{\cos \alpha}.
We also have the standard FD=sin⁡γcos⁡βFD = \sin \gamma \cos \beta and EF=sin⁡βcos⁡γEF = \sin \beta \cos \gamma. We can finally compute

f(L)=LD⋅LD′−LE⋅LE′=sin⁡α2(LD′+LE′)=sin⁡α2(FD′+FE′−FD−FE) f(L) = LD \cdot LD' - LE \cdot LE' = \frac{\sin \alpha}{2} (LD' + LE') = \frac{\sin \alpha}{2} (FD' + FE' - FD - FE)
=sin⁡α4cos⁡α(cos⁡γsin⁡(β−α)−cos⁡βsin⁡(γ−α)−2cos⁡α(sin⁡γcos⁡β−sin⁡βcos⁡γ)) \qquad = \frac{\sin \alpha}{4 \cos \alpha} (\cos \gamma \sin (\beta - \alpha) - \cos \beta \sin (\gamma - \alpha) - 2 \cos \alpha (\sin \gamma \cos \beta - \sin \beta \cos \gamma))
=3sin⁡αsin⁡(β−γ)4=34(sin⁡(β+γ)sin⁡(β−γ))=38(cos⁡(2γ)−cos⁡(2β)) \qquad = \frac{3 \sin \alpha \sin(\beta - \gamma)}{4} = \frac{3}{4} (\sin (\beta + \gamma) \sin (\beta - \gamma)) = \frac{3}{8} (\cos (2\gamma) - \cos (2\beta))
=34(sin⁡2(β)−sin⁡2(γ))=−32f(A).□ \qquad = \frac{3}{4} (\sin^{2}(\beta) - \sin^{2}(\gamma)) = -\frac{3}{2} f(A).\quad \square

Figure 4

Solution 4

Solution:

Let T=BM∩CNT = BM \cap CN, let FF be the foot of the altitude from AA to BCBC, let OO be the circumcentre of (ADE)(ADE), let D′≠DD' \neq D and E′≠EE' \neq E be the second intersections of (DHMP)(DHMP) and (EHNQ)(EHNQ) with line BCBC and let UU and VV be the antipodes of DD and EE on (DHMP)(DHMP) and (EHNQ)(EHNQ), respectively.

We begin with a bit of barycentric coordinates. Set barycentric coordinates in △ABC\triangle ABC, set so that A=(1,0,0)A = (1,0,0), B=(0,1,0)B = (0,1,0), and C=(0,0,1)C = (0,0,1). The definitions of DD and EE give D=(0,2/3,1/3)D = (0,2/3,1/3) and E=(0,1/3,2/3)E = (0,1/3,2/3), whence M=(1/2,1/3,1/6)M = (1/2,1/3,1/6) and N=(1/2,1/6,1/3)N = (1/2,1/6,1/3). This means that line BMBM is given by (1/2:y:1/6)(1/2:y:1/6) while line CNCN is given by (1/2:1/6:z)(1/2:1/6:z). So their intersection TT is (1/2:1/6:1/6)=(3:1:1)(1/2:1/6:1/6) = (3:1:1), giving T=3A+B+C5=3A+D+E5T = \frac{3A + B + C}{5} = \frac{3A + D + E}{5}.

Our next tool is the linearity of the power of a point. Let f:R2→Rf:\mathbb{R}^{2} \to \mathbb{R} be defined by

f(Z)=Pow(DHMP)(Z)−Pow(EHNQ)(Z). f(Z) = \mathrm{Pow}_{(DHMP)}(Z) - \mathrm{Pow}_{(EHNQ)}(Z).
It suffices to show that f(T)=0f(T) = 0; from there, the required concyclicity will follow from TM⋅TP=TN⋅TQTM \cdot TP = TN \cdot TQ. The key observation is that ff is a linear function. In particular, f(T)=3f(A)+f(D)+f(E)5f(T) = \frac{3f(A) + f(D) + f(E)}{5}. So, we need only show that 3f(A)+f(D)+f(E)=03f(A) + f(D) + f(E) = 0. Pick an arbitrary one-dimensional coordinate system on the line BCBC and let τ\tau be the map from a point on BCBC to its coordinate. We compute

f(A)=AM⋅AD−AN⋅AE=AD2−AE22=FD2−FE22 f(A) = AM \cdot AD - AN \cdot AE = \frac{AD^2 - AE^2}{2} = \frac{FD^2 - FE^2}{2}
=(τ(E)−τ(D))(τ(F)−τ(D+E2)), \qquad = (\tau(E) - \tau(D))\left(\tau(F) - \tau\left(\frac{D + E}{2}\right)\right),
f(D)=−DE⋅DE′=(τ(E)−τ(D))(τ(D)−τ(E′)),f(E)=ED⋅ED′=(τ(E)−τ(D))(τ(E)−τ(D′)). f(D) = -DE \cdot DE' = (\tau(E) - \tau(D))(\tau(D) - \tau(E')),\quad f(E) = ED \cdot ED' = (\tau(E) - \tau(D))(\tau(E) - \tau(D')).
Rearranging, it suffices to show that 3τ(F)=τ(D′)+τ(E′)+τ((D+E)/2)3\tau(F) = \tau(D') + \tau(E') + \tau((D + E)/2). This can be rewritten as 3F=D′+E′+(D+E)/23F = D' + E' + (D + E)/2. By projecting down to line BCBC, it suffices to show that the displacement vector H+2A−(O+U+V)H + 2A - (O + U + V) is perpendicular to line BCBC.

We do this using complex numbers. Let (ADE)(ADE) be the unit circle with A=aA = a, D=dD = d, and E=eE = e, so that O=0O = 0 and H=h=a+d+eH = h = a + d + e. Note that UU satisfies UM⊥ADUM \perp AD and UH⊥DH⊥AEUH \perp DH \perp AE. Translating these conditions into equations, we have u=adu‾u = a d\overline{u} and u+aeu‾=h+aeh‾u + a e\overline{u} = h + a e\overline{h}. Rearranging gives

v:=H+2A−(O+U+V)=h+2a−(d+e)h+2adeh‾d+e=2(a−adeh‾d+e)=−2ded+e. v := H + 2A - (O + U + V) = h + 2a - \frac{(d + e)h + 2a d e\overline{h}}{d + e} = 2\left(a - \frac{a d e\overline{h}}{d + e}\right) = -\frac{2de}{d + e}.
This displacement vector vv satisfies v=dev‾v = de\overline{v} and so it is orthogonal to line DEDE, as desired.

Solution 5

Solution:

This solution uses almost exclusively complex numbers. As in other solutions, we reduce to showing that HH, S:=(DHM)∩(EHN)S := (DHM) \cap (EHN), and T:=BM∩CNT := BM \cap CN are collinear; this is all of the synthetic information we shall use. (If one computes T=3A+D+E5T = \frac{3A + D + E}{5} using means other than complex numbers, the solution becomes much shorter.)

We use complex numbers with A=aA = a, D=dD = d, and E=eE = e on the unit circle. Note that H=a+d+eH = a + d + e, M=a+d2M = \frac{a + d}{2}, and B=2d−eB = 2d - e. We will make great use of the "arbitrary line intersection formula," which says that the intersection between lines WXWX and YZYZ can be written explicitly as

(u‾x−wx‾)(y−z)−(w−x)(y‾z−yz‾)(w‾−x‾)(y−z)−(w−x)(y‾−z‾). \frac{(\overline{u} x - w\overline{x})(y - z) - (w - x)(\overline{y} z - y\overline{z})}{(\overline{w} - \overline{x})(y - z) - (w - x)(\overline{y} - \overline{z})}.

We first use this to find T=tT = t. We compute

b−m=(2d−e)−a+d2=3d−a−2e2 b - m = (2d - e) - \frac{a + d}{2} = \frac{3d - a - 2e}{2}
b‾−m=3ae−de−2ad2ade \overline{b} - m = \frac{3a e - d e - 2a d}{2a d e}
b‾m−bm‾=2e−dde⋅a+d2−(2d−e)⋅a+d2ad=(a+d)(2ae+e2−ad−2de)2ade \overline{b} m - b\overline{m} = \frac{2e - d}{de} \cdot \frac{a + d}{2} - (2d - e) \cdot \frac{a + d}{2ad} = \frac{(a + d)(2a e + e^{2} - a d - 2d e)}{2ad e}

If E\mathcal{E} is some expression, we use the notation E−{∼}\mathcal{E} - \{\sim\} to denote E\mathcal{E} minus the expression formed by swapping dd and ee in E\mathcal{E}. We now have

t=(b‾m−bm‾)(c−n)−{∼}(b‾−m‾)(c−n)−{∼} t = \frac{(\overline{b}m - b\overline{m})(c - n) - \{\sim\}}{(\overline{b} - \overline{m})(c - n) - \{\sim\}}
=(a+d)(2ae+e2−ad−2de)(3e−a−2d)−{∼}(3ae−de−2ad)(3e−a−2d)−{∼} \quad = \frac{(a + d)(2a e + e^{2} - a d - 2d e)(3e - a - 2d) - \{\sim\}}{(3a e - d e - 2a d)(3e - a - 2d) - \{\sim\}}
=[a3(d−2e)+a2(3d2−7de+5e2)+a(2d3−d2e−3de2+3e3)+de(4d2−8de+3e2)]−{∼}[a2(2d−3e)+a(4d2−11de+9e2)+de(2d−3e)]−{∼} \quad = \frac{[a^{3}(d - 2e) + a^{2}(3d^{2} - 7d e + 5e^{2}) + a(2d^{3} - d^{2}e - 3d e^{2} + 3e^{3}) + d e(4d^{2} - 8d e + 3e^{2})] - \{\sim\}}{[a^{2}(2d - 3e) + a(4d^{2} - 11d e + 9e^{2}) + d e(2d - 3e)] - \{\sim\}}
=a3(3(d−e))−a2(2(d2−e2))+a(−(d3−e3)+2de(d−e))+de(d2−e2)a2(5(d−e))−a(5(d2−e2))+de(5(d−e)) \quad = \frac{a^{3}(3(d - e)) - a^{2}(2(d^{2} - e^{2})) + a(-(d^{3} - e^{3}) + 2d e(d - e)) + d e(d^{2} - e^{2})}{a^{2}(5(d - e)) - a(5(d^{2} - e^{2})) + d e(5(d - e))}
=3a3−2a2(d+e)−a(d2−de+e2)+de(d+e)5(a2−a(d+e)+de) \quad = \frac{3a^{3} - 2a^{2}(d + e) - a(d^{2} - d e + e^{2}) + d e(d + e)}{5(a^{2} - a(d + e) + d e)}
=(a−d)(a−e)(3a+d+e)5(a−d)(a−e)=3a+d+e5. \quad = \frac{(a - d)(a - e)(3a + d + e)}{5(a - d)(a - e)} = \frac{3a + d + e}{5}.
(The factorization in the last line can be motivated by noting that the expression, while cubic in aa, is only quadratic in dd. When written out as a polynomial in dd, each coefficient is divisible by a−ea - e; by symmetry, the numerator is divisible by a−da - d as well, and the factorization follows.)

Computing S=sS = s is slightly harder, as it is the intersection of two circles rather than of two lines. We get around this by noting that {h,d,m,s}\{h, d, m, s\} are concyclic if and only if {0,h−d,h−m,h−s}\{0, h - d, h - m, h - s\} are concyclic, which happens if and only if {1h−d,1h−m,1h−s}\{\frac{1}{h - d}, \frac{1}{h - m}, \frac{1}{h - s}\} are collinear. (One can see this by inversion, or just by writing out the cross-ratio in the special case when one of the points is zero.) Thus 1h−s\frac{1}{h - s} is the intersection of the line through w:=1h−dw := \frac{1}{h - d} and x:=1h−mx := \frac{1}{h - m} and the line through y:=1h−ey := \frac{1}{h - e} and z:=1h−nz := \frac{1}{h - n}. We compute

w−x=1a+e−1a+d2+e=−a−d(a+e)(a+d+2e) w - x = \frac{1}{a + e} - \frac{1}{\frac{a + d}{2} + e} = -\frac{a - d}{(a + e)(a + d + 2e)}
w−x‾=ae2(a−d)(a+e)(2ad+ae+de) \overline{w - x} = \frac{a e^{2}(a - d)}{(a + e)(2ad + a e + d e)}
w‾x−wx‾=aea+e⋅2a+d+2e−1a+e⋅2ade2ad+ae+de \overline{w} x - w\overline{x} = \frac{a e}{a + e} \cdot \frac{2}{a + d + 2e} - \frac{1}{a + e} \cdot \frac{2ad e}{2ad + a e + d e}
=2ae(2ad+ae+de)−d(a+d+2e)(a+e)(a+d+2e)(2ad+ae+de) \qquad = 2a e \frac{(2ad + a e + d e) - d(a + d + 2e)}{(a + e)(a + d + 2e)(2ad + a e + d e)}
=2ae(a−d)(d+e)(a+e)(a+d+2e)(2ad+ae+de). \qquad = \frac{2a e(a - d)(d + e)}{(a + e)(a + d + 2e)(2ad + a e + d e)}.

Using the line intersection formula, we have

1h−s=(w‾x−wx‾)(y−z)−{∼}(w‾−x‾)(y−z)−{∼} \frac{1}{h - s} = \frac{(\overline{w} x - w\overline{x})(y - z) - \{\sim\}}{(\overline{w} - \overline{x})(y - z) - \{\sim\}}
=2(d+e)[e(ad+2ae+de)]−{∼}[e2(a+d+2e)(ad+2ae+de)]−{∼} = 2(d + e) \frac{[e(ad + 2ae + de)] - \{\sim\}}{[e^{2}(a + d + 2e)(ad + 2ae + de)] - \{\sim\}}
=2(d+e)[a(de+2e2)+de2]−{∼}[a2(de2+2e3)+a(d2e2+5de3+4e4)+de(de2+2e3)]−{∼} = 2(d + e) \frac{[a(de + 2e^{2}) + de^{2}] - \{\sim\}}{[a^{2}(de^{2} + 2e^{3}) + a(d^{2}e^{2} + 5de^{3} + 4e^{4}) + de(de^{2} + 2e^{3})] - \{\sim\}}
=2(d+e)(a(2(e2−d2))+de(e−d))(a2+de)(2(e3−d3)+de(e−d))+a(4(e4−d4)+5de(e2−e2)) = \frac{2(d + e)(a(2(e^{2} - d^{2})) + de(e - d))}{(a^{2} + de)(2(e^{3} - d^{3}) + de(e - d)) + a(4(e^{4} - d^{4}) + 5de(e^{2} - e^{2}))}
=2(d+e)(2a(d+e)+de)(a2+de)(2d2+3de+2e2)+a(d+e)(4d2+5de+4e2). = \frac{2(d + e)(2a(d + e) + de)}{(a^{2} + de)(2d^{2} + 3de + 2e^{2}) + a(d + e)(4d^{2} + 5de + 4e^{2})}.

Since h−t=2a+4d+4e5h - t = \frac{2a + 4d + 4e}{5}, this gives us

h−sh−t=54⋅(a2+de)(2d2+3de+2e2)+a(d+e)(4d2+5de+4e2)(d+e)(2ad+2ae+de)(a+2d+2e). \frac{h - s}{h - t} = \frac{5}{4} \cdot \frac{(a^{2} + de)(2d^{2} + 3de + 2e^{2}) + a(d + e)(4d^{2} + 5de + 4e^{2})}{(d + e)(2ad + 2ae + de)(a + 2d + 2e)}.

It is easy to see that this is real by using the symmetry of the expressions (both the numerator and denominator satisfy E=a2d3e3E‾\mathcal{E} = a^{2}d^{3}e^{3}\overline{\mathcal{E}}). We conclude that HH, SS, and TT are collinear, as desired.

Solution 6

Solution:

As usual, we reduce to proving T=(3A+D+E)/5T = (3A + D + E)/5 is on the radical axis and compute; this time in Cartesian coordinates.

Let A(0,h)A(0,h), D(b,0)D(b,0), E(c,0)E(c,0) be coordinates for ADEADE. Then H(0,−bch)H(0, -\frac{bc}{h}), M(b2,h2)M(\frac{b}{2}, \frac{h}{2}), N(c2,h2)N(\frac{c}{2}, \frac{h}{2}) and T(b+c5,3h5)T(\frac{b + c}{5}, \frac{3h}{5}). We compute OD(xD,yD)O_{D}(x_{D}, y_{D}) the circumcentre of DMHDMH and obtain OEO_{E} by symmetry. We then have to verify that ODOE⊥HTO_{D}O_{E} \perp HT, which can be done by comparing slopes.

The centre ODO_{D} can be given by the intersection of perpendicular bisectors of DMDM and DHDH. This gives the following system of equations on xD,yDx_{D}, y_{D}:

h⋅xD+c⋅yD=bh2−bc22h h \cdot x_{D} + c \cdot y_{D} = \frac{b h}{2} - \frac{b c^{2}}{2 h}
−b⋅xD+h⋅yD=−3b24+h24 -b \cdot x_{D} + h \cdot y_{D} = -\frac{3 b^{2}}{4} + \frac{h^{2}}{4}
Solving the system gives

(h2+bc)(xD−xE)=b−c4(5bc+3h2) (h^{2} + b c)(x_{D} - x_{E}) = \frac{b - c}{4} (5b c + 3h^{2})
(h2+bc)(yD−yE)=−b−c4h(b+c) (h^{2} + b c)(y_{D} - y_{E}) = -\frac{b - c}{4} h(b + c)
So yD−yExD−xE=−h(b+c)5bc+3h2\frac{y_{D} - y_{E}}{x_{D} - x_{E}} = -\frac{h(b + c)}{5b c + 3h^{2}}.

The other slope is more immediate:

yT−yHxT−xH=3h/5+bc/h(b+c)/5=5bc+3h2h(b+c)=−xD−xEyD−yE \frac{y_{T} - y_{H}}{x_{T} - x_{H}} = \frac{3h / 5 + b c / h}{(b + c) / 5} = \frac{5b c + 3h^{2}}{h(b + c)} = -\frac{x_{D} - x_{E}}{y_{D} - y_{E}}
so indeed the two slopes correspond to perpendicular lines.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.