A deck consists of cards, each colored red, green and blue in denominations through . We choose a subset of the denominations and deal all cards of the chosen denominations into three equal size hands to players designated red, green and blue in such a way that no player receives a card of her own color. Prove that the number of deals for which the denominations appearing in the red player's hand are equals . (So it doesn't depend on the size of .)
, 2011
Solution
Partition the set of denominations occurring in red's hand into three blocks: , those appearing on both blue and green cards (in red's hand); , those appearing on blue cards only; , those appearing on green cards only. Set , , . Thus and is the size of each hand. This implies that the number of denominations not in but involved in the deal is ; call this set . The green cards with denominations in must occur in blue's hand. This accounts for cards in blue's hand and so the rest of her hand must consist of red cards. Thus the deal is determined by a choice of the sets and ( is then determined), the set , and a choice of red cards (from the available) for blue's hand. These choices are counted by the sum over nonnegative and of the product
This sum can be written
The inner sum equals , independent of (we have candies and toffees and want to choose sweeties), and then the first sum equals .