Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /26 of 30

Combinatorics Difficulty 6.7 National Olympiad Find the answer Italy

Problem:

Giovanni draws a regular 9-gon in pencil and connects each of its vertices to the center, drawing a total of 18 segments and thus obtaining nine triangles. He then traces over some of the drawn segments in pen, in such a way that in the end each of the nine triangles has exactly one side traced over in pen. In how many ways can Giovanni choose the set of segments to trace over? (Note: two sets of segments obtained one from the other by rotation or by symmetry are to be considered distinct.)

Pick one

Solution

Solution:

We will call radii the 9 segments that have the center of the 9-gon as a vertex.
Note first of all that choosing the set of segments to trace over in pen is equivalent to choosing a subset of the 9 radii that does not contain two consecutive radii: naturally Giovanni cannot trace over two consecutive radii; on the other hand, once the radii to be traced over have been chosen, each side of the 9-gon will be traced over if and only if neither of the two radii sharing a vertex with that side has been traced over.
We count the possible configurations according to the number of radii traced over.

0 - a single configuration;

1 - 9 choices for the radius to be traced over;

2 - once a radius has been chosen, the second radius can be any of the remaining ones, except for the two neighbors of the initial radius; the number of configurations is thus half the number of ordered pairs obtained in this way (1296)\left(\frac{1}{2} 9 \cdot 6\right), that is, 27;

3 - the total number of possible choices for a subset of three radii, ignoring the restriction, is 16987\frac{1}{6} 9 \cdot 8 \cdot 7, that is, 84; among these, exactly 9 are choices of three consecutive radii; it remains to decide how many configurations there are formed by two consecutive radii and a third radius not consecutive to either of the other two. The pair of consecutive radii can be chosen in 9 ways; at that point, there are 5 choices for the 'isolated' radius. It follows that there are 84945=3084-9-45=30 acceptable configurations;

4 - in this case there is exactly one pair of chosen radii separated by a pair of consecutive unchosen radii (outside of this interval, chosen and unchosen radii alternate); the configurations are as many as the pairs of consecutive radii, that is, 9.

In total, we count 1+9+27+30+9=761+9+27+30+9=76 possible configurations.

Let us consider a variant of the original problem: Giovanni draws a regular nn-gon in pencil, then draws nn segments joining the vertices to the center; nn triangles are thus formed. Unlike the original problem, suppose that Giovanni chooses one of the segments having the center as a vertex and decides not to trace it over in pen: we will call this segment special. Let us call f(n)f(n) the number of ways Giovanni has available to choose a subset of the other 2n12 n-1 segments to trace over, again in such a way that each of the nn triangles ends up with exactly one segment traced over in pen.
Note that, if n>4,f(n)=f(n1)+f(n2)n>4, f(n)=f(n-1)+f(n-2). Consider the triangle lying to the right of the special segment; it must have a segment traced over in pen, which can be a side of the nn-gon or a segment having the center as a vertex. If Giovanni traces over the side of the nn-gon in pen, he has f(n1)f(n-1) ways of choosing the other segments to trace over: he can remove the traced-over side and identify the other two sides of the triangle in question, making them the special segment of a new configuration with n1n-1 triangles. If Giovanni traces over the side of the triangle adjacent to the center of the nn-gon, then he cannot trace over any other side of the triangle lying to its right; he can thus remove two triangles, as in the previous step, to obtain a configuration with n2n-2 triangles and a special segment.
We now show that the answer to the original problem is f(7)+f(9)f(7)+f(9). Let us choose any one of the radii of the 9-gon. If this is not traced over, then we can consider it as the special segment: there are f(9)f(9) ways of choosing the segments to trace over; otherwise, we can remove the two triangles adjacent to it, identifying the two radii between which they are contained: the identified radii cannot be traced over, and are thus a special segment for the configuration with 7 triangles.
It is easy to verify that f(3)=3f(3)=3 and f(4)=5f(4)=5 by enumerating the configurations; consequently, f(5)=8;f(6)=13;f(7)=21;f(8)=34;f(9)=55f(5)=8 ; f(6)=13 ; f(7)=21 ; f(8)=34 ; f(9)=55. The answer is f(7)+f(9)f(7)+f(9), that is, 76.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from it; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.