Let f:R→R be a continuous, bounded and non-constant function satisfying f(2x)=2f(x)2−1 for all x∈R. Show that the equation f(x)=0 has a solution.
Solution
By the intermediate value theorem, it suffices to prove that f takes both non-negative and non-positive values.
**Case f≥0:** Suppose that f(x)≥0 for all x∈R. Then we have f(x)=21+f(2x) for all x∈R. Since the function ϕ:[0,∞)→[0,∞),t↦21+t, is strictly increasing we see that f≥21. In fact, for the sequence defined by t0=0 and tn=ϕ(tn−1), n≥1, we have f≥tn for all n by induction. However, it is easy to see that tn↗1. Thus we see that f≥1. Now suppose that for some x0∈R, we have f(x0)>1. Then f(2x0)=f(x0)2+f(x0)2−1>f(x0)2>1. By induction, we have f(2nx0)>f(x0)2n for all n∈Z≥1, which contradicts the boundedness of f. Hence f≤1 and thus f=1, which is impossible since f is non-constant.
**Case f≤0:** Suppose that f(x)≤0 for all x∈R. Then we have f(x)=−21+f(2x) for all x∈R. Note that the function ψ:[−1,0]→[−1,0],t↦−21+t, is strictly decreasing. Thus for the sequence defined by s0=0 and sn=ϕ(sn−1), n≥1, we have s2n+1≤f≤s2n for all n≥0 by induction. Moreover, it is clear that s0≥s2≥s4≥… and s1≤s3≤s5≤… so we consider the limits s2n↘a and s2n+1↗b. Clearly, both a and b are solutions of the equation ψ(ψ(s))=s belonging to the interval [−1,0]. However, it is easy to check that the solutions of ψ(ψ(s))=s are roots of the polynomial P(s)=8s4−8s2−s+1=(s−1)(2s+1)(4s2+2s−1). But s=−1/2 is the only root of P(s) in the interval [−1,0], thus a=b=−1/2. Hence f is constant, a contradiction.
Combining the cases we get the solution.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.