Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / Iranian Mathematical Olympiad /250 of 270

Iranian Mathematical Olympiad

Algebra Difficulty 7.6 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Iran

Prove there are coprime polynomials P(x)P(x) and Q(x)Q(x) with integer coefficients and a real number u>0u > 0 such that if
∣ac−1∣2021≤udc1010,∣(ac)2020−bd∣≤udc1010, \left| \frac{a}{c} - 1 \right|^{2021} \leq \frac{u}{d c^{1010}}, \quad \left| \left( \frac{a}{c} \right)^{2020} - \frac{b}{d} \right| \leq \frac{u}{d c^{1010}},
for some positive integers a,b,c,da, b, c, d, then we have bP(ac)=dQ(ac)bP\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) = dQ\left(\frac{a}{c}\right).

Solution

We shall prove a more general statement in the following lines.
Proposition. Let kk be a positive integer. Prove that for all pairs (c,d)(c, d) of integers such that ∣c∣|c| and ∣d∣|d| are prime numbers there is a positive integer NN such that the number of pairs (a,b)(a, b) of integers satisfying the following inequalities is at most NN, for all sufficiently small positive real numbers u,vu, v.
∣b∣∣a−c∣2021≤u∣c∣1011,∣akb−ckd∣≤v∣c∣k−1010. |b||a-c|^{2021} \le u|c|^{1011}, \quad |a^k b - c^k d| \le v|c|^{k-1010}.
Let us rewrite the original inequalities as ∣b∣∣ac−1∣2021≤u∣c∣−1010|b|\left|\frac{a}{c} - 1\right|^{2021} \le u|c|^{-1010} and ∣(ac)kb−d∣≤v∣c∣−1010\left|\left(\frac{a}{c}\right)^k b - d\right| \le v|c|^{-1010}. Then if k≤1010k \le 1010 then akb=ckda^k b = c^k d and hence, we only have finitely many solutions for a,ba, b. Hence, assume that k>1010k > 1010. We then prove the following lemma:
Lemma. There are polynomials P(x),Q(x)P(x), Q(x) of degree 10101010 with integer coefficients such that the polynomial P(x)−xkQ(x)P(x) - x^k Q(x) has a 20212021-fold zero at x=1x = 1.
Proof. We shall prove that for all triples (m,n,k)(m, n, k) of natural numbers such that n>kn > k there are polynomials P(x)=P(m,n,k)(x)P(x) = P_{(m,n,k)}(x), Q(x)=Q(m,n,k)(x)Q(x) = Q_{(m,n,k)}(x) of degrees m,nm, n with rational coefficients such that P(x)−xkQ(x)P(x) - x^k Q(x) is divisible by (x−1)m+n+1(x-1)^{m+n+1}. We shall prove this through induction, considering the following expression:
x(P(m,n−1,k)(x)−xkQ(m,n−1,k)(x))+r(P(m−1,n,k)(x)−xkQ(m−1,n,k)(x)). x (P_{(m,n-1,k)}(x) - x^k Q_{(m,n-1,k)}(x)) + r (P_{(m-1,n,k)}(x) - x^k Q_{(m-1,n,k)}(x)).
Since both brackets are divisible by (x−1)m+n(x-1)^{m+n} then there would be a rational number rr such that the above expression is divisible by (x−1)m+n+1(x-1)^{m+n+1} then defining P(m,n,k)(x)=xP(m,n−1,k)(x)+rP(m−1,n,k)(x)P_{(m,n,k)}(x) = xP_{(m,n-1,k)}(x) + rP_{(m-1,n,k)}(x) and Q(m,n,k)(x)=xQ(m,n−1,k)(x)+Q(m−1,n,k)(x)Q_{(m,n,k)}(x) = xQ_{(m,n-1,k)}(x) + Q_{(m-1,n,k)}(x). Moreover, for the base case, that is when one of m,nm, n are zero, the statement is obvious. This completes our proof.

Comment 1. If P(m,n,k)(0)=0P_{(m,n,k)}(0) = 0 for some non-zero m,nm, n then the polynomial P(m,n,k)(x)−xkQ(m,n,k)(x)P_{(m,n,k)}(x) - x^k Q_{(m,n,k)}(x) has at most m+nm+n non-zero coefficients, impossible.
Lemma. P(m,n,k)(x),Q(m,n,k)(x)P_{(m,n,k)}(x), Q_{(m,n,k)}(x) have no common factor.
Proof. Assume for the contradiction that there is a non constant polynomial D(x)D(x) of degree dd dividing both of them. Then at least (x−1)m+n+1−d(x-1)^{m+n+1-d} divides P(m,n,k)(x)D(x)−xkQ(m,n,k)(x)D(x)\frac{P_{(m,n,k)}(x)}{D(x)} - x^k \frac{Q_{(m,n,k)}(x)}{D(x)}. Since the not-zero coefficient of this polynomial is at most m+n−2d+2m+n-2d+2. But, according to our lemma 2 it must at least have m+n+2−dm+n+2-d non-zero coefficients. Therefore, d≤0d \le 0. This completes our proof.

Now, there are coprime polynomials P(x),Q(x)P(x), Q(x) of degree 10101010 with integer coefficients such that P(x)−xkQ(x)P(x) - x^k Q(x) is divisible by (x−1)2021(x-1)^{2021} and hence there are polynomials A(x),B(x)A(x), B(x) with integer coefficients of the same degree that doesn't exceed 10101010 such that
A(x)P(x)+B(x)Q(x)=R,(1) A(x)P(x) + B(x)Q(x) = R, \quad (1)
for some non-zero constant RR.
Lemma. If a,b,ca, b, c and dd satisfy the statement of our problem then bP(ac)=dQ(ac)bP\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) = dQ\left(\frac{a}{c}\right).
Proof. We prove the lemma for polynomial P(x)−xkQ(x)P(x) - x^k Q(x), for some positive integer k≥deg⁡P(x)=deg⁡Q(x)=dk \ge \deg P(x) = \deg Q(x) = d. Then, the second inequality becomes ∣akb−ckd∣≤v∣c∣k−1010|a^k b - c^k d| \le v|c|^{k-1010}. Since ∣b∣≥1|b| \ge 1, take u<1u < 1 then ∣a−c∣≤∣c∣|a-c| \le |c| therefore, ∣a∣≤2∣c∣|a| \le 2|c|. Moreover, let d=1010d = 1010, and R(x)=P(x)−xkQ(x)R(x) = P(x) - x^k Q(x), the following quantity is an integer:
cd(bP(ac)−dQ(ac))=bcdR(ac)+(akb−ckd)cd−kQ(ac). c^d \left( bP\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) - dQ\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) \right) = bc^d R\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) + (a^k b - c^k d) c^{d-k} Q\left(\frac{a}{c}\right).
Now, if bP(ac)≠dQ(ac)bP(\frac{a}{c}) \neq dQ(\frac{a}{c}) then, ∣cd(bP(ac)−dQ(ac))∣≥1|c^d (bP(\frac{a}{c}) - dQ(\frac{a}{c}))| \ge 1. Thus, by triangle inequality, we find that
∣bcdR(ac)∣+∣(akb−ckd)cd−kQ(ac)∣≥1. |bc^d R\left(\frac{a}{c}\right)| + \left| (a^k b - c^k d) c^{d-k} Q\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) \right| \ge 1.
Write R(x)=(1−x)2d+1S(x)R(x) = (1-x)^{2d+1} S(x) then, bcdR(ac)=bcd(1−ac)2d+1S(ac)=c−d−1b(c−a)2d+1S(ac)bc^d R\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) = bc^d (1-\frac{a}{c})^{2d+1} S\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) = c^{-d-1} b(c-a)^{2d+1} S\left(\frac{a}{c}\right). Thus,
∣c−d−1b(c−a)2d+1S(ac)∣+∣(akb−ckd)cd−kQ(ac)∣≥1. |c^{-d-1} b(c-a)^{2d+1} S\left(\frac{a}{c}\right)| + \left| (a^k b - c^k d) c^{d-k} Q\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) \right| \ge 1.
That is, ∣b∣∣c−a∣2d+1∣c−d−1∣∣S(ac)∣+∣akb−ckd∣∣cd−k∣∣Q(ac)∣≥1|b||c-a|^{2d+1} |c^{-d-1}| |S(\frac{a}{c})| + |a^k b - c^k d| |c^{d-k}| |Q(\frac{a}{c})| \ge 1. By use of problem's assumption, we find for all u,vu, v: ∣u∣∣S(ac)∣+∣v∣∣Q(ac)∣≥1|u| |S(\frac{a}{c})| + |v| |Q(\frac{a}{c})| \ge 1.

Assume that S(x)=ck−d−1xk−d−1+⋯+c0S(x) = c_{k-d-1}x^{k-d-1} + \cdots + c_0 be a polynomial with integer coefficients. Then, ∣S(ac)∣≤∑i=0k−d−1∣ci∣2i=C1|S(\frac{a}{c})| \le \sum_{i=0}^{k-d-1} |c_i|2^i = C_1 which is a constant number. Furthermore, by the same argument we can find that ∣Q(ac)∣≤C2|Q(\frac{a}{c})| \le C_2 for some constant C2C_2. This yields to:
uC1+vC2≥1. u C_1 + vC_2 \ge 1.
The last inequality would be absurd for all sufficiently small u,vu, v. We are done.

Putting x=acx = \frac{a}{c} in (1) and multiply both sides by c2020c^{2020} it follows that
c1010A(ac)c1010P(ac)+c1010B(ac)c1010Q(ac)=c2020R. c^{1010}A\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) c^{1010}P\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) + c^{1010}B\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) c^{1010}Q\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) = c^{2020}R.
Now, using lemma 4 yielding to
c1010P(ac)(dc1010A(ac)+bc1010B(ac))=c2020dR. c^{1010} P\left(\frac{a}{c}\right) \left( d c^{1010} A\left(\frac{a}{c}\right)+b c^{1010} B\left(\frac{a}{c}\right)\right) = c^{2020} d R.
Note that if gcd⁡(a,c)>1\gcd(a, c) > 1 then cc must divide aa. But then, ∣b∣∣a−c∣2021≤u∣c∣1011|b||a-c|^{2021} \le u|c|^{1011} becomes ∣b∣ac−1∣c∣2021≤u∣c∣−1010|b|^{\frac{a}{c}-1}|c|^{2021} \le u|c|^{-1010}. Hence, it follows that a=ca=c. Thus, assume that gcd⁡(a,c)=1\gcd(a, c) = 1.
Hence, c1010P(ac)c^{1010}P(\frac{a}{c}) divides c2020dRc^{2020}dR. Note that
gcd⁡(c1010P(ac),c)=gcd⁡(c,a1010a1010)=gcd⁡(c,a1010)=g≤∣a1010∣, \gcd\left(c^{1010}P\left(\frac{a}{c}\right), c\right) = \gcd\left(c, a_{1010}a^{1010}\right) = \gcd(c, a_{1010}) = g \le |a_{1010}|,
where a1010a_{1010} is the leading coefficient of P(x)P(x). Writing c=gfc = gf, gcd⁡(f,a1010)=1\gcd(f, a_{1010}) = 1 it follows that c1010P(ac)c^{1010}P(\frac{a}{c}) divides g2020dRg^{2020}dR. Since the number of divisors of Rdg2020Rdg^{2020} is at most 2∣R∣g2020≤2∣R∣a101020202|R|g^{2020} \le 2|R|a_{1010}^{2020}, hence the total number of possibilities for aa is at most 2020∣R∣a101020202020|R|a_{1010}^{2020}. Finally for each certain a,b=dQ(ac)P(ac)a, b = \frac{dQ(\frac{a}{c})}{P(\frac{a}{c})} would be determined uniquely. Moreover, note that P(ac)≠0P(\frac{a}{c}) \ne 0 because otherwise, P,QP, Q will have a common factor. Since RR only depends on the coefficients of P(x),Q(x)P(x), Q(x) we can put N=2020∣R∣a10102020N = 2020|R|a_{1010}^{2020}. ■

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.