Problem:
For all positive integers , prove that
(For a positive integer , denotes the number of positive integers less than or equal to and relatively prime to . For a real number , denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to .)
Problem:
For all positive integers , prove that
(For a positive integer , denotes the number of positive integers less than or equal to and relatively prime to . For a real number , denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to .)
Solution:
Consider the fractions , where and range over integers such that . We will count these fractions in two ways:
a. By unreduced form. For each denominator , there are possible numerators , so the total number of fractions is
b. By reduced form. Suppose a fraction has been reduced to . Given the denominator , there are possible numerators such that and is in lowest terms. To get from back to , we must multiply numerator and denominator by a positive integer such that . Since always holds if , the choice of is limited only by the inequality , which has solutions. Thus there are fractions for a given choice of , so the total number of fractions is
Since both methods of counting must yield the same answer, the identity follows.