Let be a sequence of real numbers such that , and for every there exists satisfying
Find the maximum possible value of .
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
The claimed maximal value is achieved at
Now we need to show that this value is optimal. For brevity, we use the notation
In particular, and . In these terms, for every integer there exists a positive integer such that .
For every integer we define
By definition, for all ; on the other hand,
Therefore,
Also by definition, for any we have
notice that these inequalities are also valid for .
Claim 1. For every , we have .
Proof. Choose positive integers such that and . We have
so
since
Similarly, we get
Since and , the obtained inequalities yield
Back to the problem, if for all , then and hence
Otherwise, let be the minimal index with . We have for all , while . Therefore, yields
Now we have
and
This gives us
so
Solution 2
We present a different proof of the estimate .
We keep the same notations of , and from the previous solution.
Notice that , as . Also notice that for we have
Proof. Choose a positive integer such that
Then we have
which establishes the first inequality in the Claim. The proof of the second inequality is similar.
Proof. By Claim 2, we have
Since , the claim follows.
Proof. We use induction on . The case is routine. To perform the induction step, we need to prove the inequalities
for every positive integer . Clearly, these inequalities hold for and , as . In the sequel, we assume that .
Now the first inequality in Eq. (1) rewrites as
or, cancelling the terms occurring on both parts, as
By the induction hypothesis, we have .
By Claim 3, we get for all . Summing these inequalities we obtain
as required.
The second inequality in Eq. (1) is proved similarly. Indeed, this inequality is equivalent to
the last inequality follows again from Claim 3, as each term in is at most .
Now we can prove the required estimate for . Set . By Claim 4,
On the other hand, the same Claim yields
Noticing that each term in is at most 1, so
we finally obtain