Problem:
Let be positive integers with . Let be the set of pairs of relatively prime positive integers such that and .
For each pair , consider the nonnegative integer solution to the equation chosen with minimal, and let denote the (open) interval .
Prove that for every , and that any fixed irrational number lies in for exactly distinct pairs .
, 2015
Solution
Solution:
The fact that follows from the small-ness of : the smallest solution has , so forces .
For the main part of the problem, it suffices (actually, is equivalent) to show that
(i) each appear exactly times as endpoints of intervals ; and
(ii) each reduced rational appears an equal (possibly zero, if is large) number of times as left and right endpoints of intervals .
We prove these separately as follows:
(i) is a (left) endpoint precisely when , or equivalently has (look at mod ). Since , we get good pairs for fixed . Indeed, for any coprime residue class modulo , there's exactly one representative with . (Conceptually, it may be enlightening to think of as part of the Euclidean algorithm tree generated by .)
Thus occurs as an endpoint times. Similarly, is an endpoint precisely when , or equivalently has (look at ). By the same reasoning as before, we get right endpoint occurrences of .
(ii) Fix with coprime, so . We want to show that occurs for the same number of as occurs for . (In fact, we will show that the number of occurrences of the former in equals the number of the latter in .) The former occurs precisely when , , and (given the first two conditions) . Given the first two conditions, the third is equivalent to , or . This is equivalent to having and .
Similarly, the latter occurs precisely when , , , and .
As hinted at before, if we consider the occurrences for a fixed value , then the number of permitted residue classes (in the former) is the same as the number of permitted residue classes (in the latter): is permitted in the former if and only if is permitted in the latter; note that if and only if .