Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / IMO Shortlist /267 of 365

IMO Shortlist, 2006

Geometry Difficulty 8.8 Shortlist Prove it IMO

Let ABCDABCD be a convex quadrilateral. A circle passing through the points AA and DD and a circle passing through the points BB and CC are externally tangent at a point PP inside the quadrilateral. Suppose that
∠PAB+∠PDC≤90∘ and ∠PBA+∠PCD≤90∘. \angle PAB + \angle PDC \leq 90^{\circ} \quad \text{ and } \quad \angle PBA + \angle PCD \leq 90^{\circ}.
Prove that AB+CD≥BC+ADAB + CD \geq BC + AD.

Solution

We start with a preliminary observation. Let TT be a point inside the quadrilateral ABCDABCD. Then:
Circles (BCT) and (DAT) are tangent at Tif and only if∠ADT+∠BCT=∠ATB. \begin{align*} & \text{Circles } (BCT) \text{ and } (DAT) \text{ are tangent at } T \\ & \text{if and only if} \quad \angle ADT + \angle BCT = \angle ATB. \tag{1} \end{align*}
Indeed, if the two circles touch each other then their common tangent at TT intersects the segment ABAB at a point ZZ, and so ∠ADT=∠ATZ\angle ADT = \angle ATZ, ∠BCT=∠BTZ\angle BCT = \angle BTZ, by the tangent-chord theorem. Thus ∠ADT+∠BCT=∠ATZ+∠BTZ=∠ATB\angle ADT + \angle BCT = \angle ATZ + \angle BTZ = \angle ATB.
And conversely, if ∠ADT+∠BCT=∠ATB\angle ADT + \angle BCT = \angle ATB then one can draw from TT a ray TZTZ with ZZ on ABAB so that ∠ADT=∠ATZ\angle ADT = \angle ATZ, ∠BCT=∠BTZ\angle BCT = \angle BTZ. The first of these equalities implies that TZTZ is tangent to the circle (DAT)(DAT); by the second equality, TZTZ is tangent to the circle (BCT)(BCT), so the two circles are tangent at TT.

Figure 1

So the equivalence (1) is settled. It will be used later on. Now pass to the actual solution. Its key idea is to introduce the circumcircles of triangles ABPABP and CDPCDP and to consider their second intersection QQ (assume for the moment that they indeed meet at two distinct points PP and QQ).

Since the point AA lies outside the circle (BCP)(BCP), we have ∠BCP+∠BAP<180∘\angle BCP + \angle BAP < 180^{\circ}. Therefore the point CC lies outside the circle (ABP)(ABP). Analogously, DD also lies outside that circle. It follows that PP and QQ lie on the same arc⁡CD\operatorname{arc} CD of the circle (BCP)(BCP).

Figure 2

By symmetry, PP and QQ lie on the same arc ABAB of the circle (ABP)(ABP). Thus the point QQ lies either inside the angle BPCBPC or inside the angle APDAPD. Without loss of generality assume that QQ lies inside the angle BPCBPC. Then
∠AQD=∠PQA+∠PQD=∠PBA+∠PCD≤90∘. \begin{equation*} \angle AQD = \angle PQA + \angle PQD = \angle PBA + \angle PCD \leq 90^{\circ}. \tag{2} \end{equation*}
by the condition of the problem.

In the cyclic quadrilaterals APQBAPQB and DPQCDPQC, the angles at vertices AA and DD are acute. So their angles at QQ are obtuse. This implies that QQ lies not only inside the angle BPCBPC but in fact inside the triangle BPCBPC, hence also inside the quadrilateral ABCDABCD.

Now an argument similar to that used in deriving (2) shows that
∠BQC=∠PAB+∠PDC≤90∘. \begin{equation*} \angle BQC = \angle PAB + \angle PDC \leq 90^{\circ}. \tag{3} \end{equation*}
Moreover, since ∠PCQ=∠PDQ\angle PCQ = \angle PDQ, we get
∠ADQ+∠BCQ=∠ADP+∠PDQ+∠BCP−∠PCQ=∠ADP+∠BCP. \angle ADQ + \angle BCQ = \angle ADP + \angle PDQ + \angle BCP - \angle PCQ = \angle ADP + \angle BCP.
The last sum is equal to ∠APB\angle APB, according to the observation (1) applied to T=PT = P. And because ∠APB=∠AQB\angle APB = \angle AQB, we obtain
∠ADQ+∠BCQ=∠AQB. \angle ADQ + \angle BCQ = \angle AQB.
Applying now (1) to T=QT = Q we conclude that the circles (BCQ)(BCQ) and (DAQ)(DAQ) are externally tangent at QQ. (We have assumed P≠QP \neq Q; but if P=QP = Q then the last conclusion holds trivially.)

Finally consider the halfdiscs with diameters BCBC and DADA constructed inwardly to the quadrilateral ABCDABCD. They have centres at MM and NN, the midpoints of BCBC and DADA respectively. In view of (2) and (3), these two halfdiscs lie entirely inside the circles (BQC)(BQC) and (AQD)(AQD); and since these circles are tangent, the two halfdiscs cannot overlap. Hence MN≥12BC+12DAMN \geq \frac{1}{2} BC + \frac{1}{2} DA.

On the other hand, since MN→=12(BA→+CD→)\overrightarrow{MN} = \frac{1}{2}(\overrightarrow{BA} + \overrightarrow{CD}), we have MN≤12(AB+CD)MN \leq \frac{1}{2}(AB + CD). Thus indeed AB+CD≥BC+DAAB + CD \geq BC + DA, as claimed.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.