Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /6 of 6

Algebra Difficulty 7.8 National olympiad, round 2 Prove it South Korea

For a given positive integer kk, define two sequences {an}\{a_n\} and {bn}\{b_n\} as follows:
a1=k,a2=k,an+2=anan+1(n1)b1=1,b2=k,bn+2=bn+13+1bn(n1) \begin{aligned} a_1 &= k, & a_2 &= k, & a_{n+2} &= a_n a_{n+1} \quad (n \ge 1) \\ b_1 &= 1, & b_2 &= k, & b_{n+2} &= \frac{b_{n+1}^3 + 1}{b_n} \quad (n \ge 1) \end{aligned}
For any positive integer nn, show that a2nbn+3a_{2n}b_{n+3} is an integer.

Solution

Lemma 2. For an odd prime pp such that pkp|k, (cm,p)=1(c_m, p) = 1 (1mn+1-1 \le m \le n+1).

*Proof.* Suppose there is an odd prime pp such that p(cm,cm+1)p|(c_m, c_{m+1}). Then Lemma 1 implies pkp|k, which contradicts Lemma 2. \square

Lemma 4. For an odd prime pp such that pmcnp^m||c_n with m1m \ge 1, pm(cn+13+k3f2n+2)p^m|(c_{n+1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n+2}}).

*Proof.* From Lemma 3, pcn1p \nmid c_{n-1}. From this computation
cn+2=cn+13+k3f2n+2cn=cn13cn+13+cn13k3f2n+2cn13cn=(cn3+k3fn)3+cn13k3f2n+2cn13cn=cn9+3cn6k3f2n+3cn3k6f2n+k9f2n+cn13k3f2n+2cn13cn=cn9+3cn6k3f2n+3cn3k6f2n+k3f2n+2(cn13+k3f2n2)cn13cn=cn9+3cn6k3f2n+3cn3k6f2n+k3f2n+2cn2cncn13cn=1cn13(cn8+3cn5k3f2n+3cn2k6f2n+k3f2n+2cn2) \begin{align*} c_{n+2} &= \frac{c_{n+1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n+2}}}{c_n} = \frac{c_{n-1}^3 c_{n+1}^3 + c_{n-1}^3 k^{3f_{2n+2}}}{c_{n-1}^3 c_n} = \frac{(c_n^3 + k^{3f_n})^3 + c_{n-1}^3 k^{3f_{2n+2}}}{c_{n-1}^3 c_n} \\ &= \frac{c_n^9 + 3c_n^6 k^{3f_{2n}} + 3c_n^3 k^{6f_{2n}} + k^{9f_{2n}} + c_{n-1}^3 k^{3f_{2n+2}}}{c_{n-1}^3 c_n} \\ &= \frac{c_n^9 + 3c_n^6 k^{3f_{2n}} + 3c_n^3 k^{6f_{2n}} + k^{3f_{2n+2}}(c_{n-1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n-2}})}{c_{n-1}^3 c_n} \tag{9} \\ &= \frac{c_n^9 + 3c_n^6 k^{3f_{2n}} + 3c_n^3 k^{6f_{2n}} + k^{3f_{2n+2}} c_{n-2} c_n}{c_{n-1}^3 c_n} \\ &= \frac{1}{c_{n-1}^3} (c_n^8 + 3c_n^5 k^{3f_{2n}} + 3c_n^2 k^{6f_{2n}} + k^{3f_{2n+2}} c_{n-2}) \end{align*}
the lemma follows. \square

For a positive integer nn, if 2αn2^\alpha||n with a nonnegative integer α\alpha, we define v(n)=αv(n) = \alpha. For a positive rational number q=mnq = \frac{m}{n} with integers mm and nn, define v(q)=v(m)v(n)v(q) = v(m) - v(n).

Lemma 5. If k0(mod4)k \equiv 0 \pmod 4, v(cn)=f2nv(c_n) = f_{2n} for n1n \ge 1.

*Proof.* We get v(c1)=1=f2v(c_1) = 1 = f_2 and v(c2)=v(c13+k3)v(b3)=3v(c1)=3=f4v(c_2) = v(c_1^3 + k^3) - v(b_3) = 3v(c_1) = 3 = f_4. Suppose v(cn)=f2nv(c_n) = f_{2n} and v(cn+1)=f2n+2v(c_{n+1}) = f_{2n+2}. Since v(cn+13)=3f2n+2<3f2n+2v(k)=v(k3f2n+2)v(c_{n+1}^3) = 3f_{2n+2} < 3f_{2n+2}v(k) = v(k^{3f_{2n+2}}), Lemma 1 implies v(cn+2)=v(cn+13+k3f2n+2)v(cn)=3f2n+2f2n=f2n+4v(c_{n+2}) = v(c_{n+1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n+2}}) - v(c_n) = 3f_{2n+2} - f_{2n} = f_{2n+4}. \square

Lemma 6. Suppose k2(mod4)k \equiv 2 \pmod 4 and If n2(mod3)n \equiv 2 \pmod 3, then v(cn)>f2nv(c_n) > f_{2n}. If n≢2(mod3)n \not\equiv 2 \pmod 3, then v(cn)=f2nv(c_n) = f_{2n}.

*Proof.* Since c1=1c_{-1} = 1, v(c1)=0>f2=1v(c_{-1}) = 0 > f_{-2} = -1. Since c0=k3+1c_0 = k^3 + 1, v(c0)=0=f0v(c_0) = 0 = f_0. From c1=(k3+1)3+12(mod8)c_1 = (k^3 + 1)^3 + 1 \equiv 2 \pmod 8, we have v(c1)=1=f2v(c_1) = 1 = f_2.
Since v(c1)=v(k)=1v(c_1) = v(k) = 1 and v(b3)=0v(b_3) = 0, c2=c13+k3b3c_2 = \frac{c_1^3 + k^3}{b_3} implies v(c2)>3=f4v(c_2) > 3 = f_4.

Suppose v(c3m)=f6mv(c_{3m}) = f_{6m} and v(c3m+1)=f6m+2v(c_{3m+1}) = f_{6m+2}. Since v(c3m+13)=3f6m+2v(c_{3m+1}^3) = 3f_{6m+2} and v(k3f6m+2)=3f6m+2v(k^{3f_{6m+2}}) = 3f_{6m+2}, we get v(c3m+13+k3f6m+2)>3f6m+2v(c_{3m+1}^3 + k^{3f_{6m+2}}) > 3f_{6m+2}. Thus v(c3m+2)=v(c3m+13+k3f6m+2)v(c3m)>3f6m+2f6m=f6m+4v(c_{3m+2}) = v(c_{3m+1}^3 + k^{3f_{6m+2}}) - v(c_{3m}) > 3f_{6m+2} - f_{6m} = f_{6m+4}.

Suppose v(c3m+1)=f6m+2v(c_{3m+1}) = f_{6m+2} and v(c3m+2)>f6m+4v(c_{3m+2}) > f_{6m+4}. Since v(c3m+23)>3f6m+4v(c_{3m+2}^3) > 3f_{6m+4} and v(k3f6m+4)=3f6m+4v(k^{3f_{6m+4}}) = 3f_{6m+4}, we have v(c3m+23+k3f6m+4)=3f6m+4v(c_{3m+2}^3 + k^{3f_{6m+4}}) = 3f_{6m+4}. Therefore, v(c3m+3)=v(c3m+23+k3f6m+4)v(c3m+1)=3f6m+4f6m+2=f6m+6v(c_{3m+3}) = v(c_{3m+2}^3 + k^{3f_{6m+4}}) - v(c_{3m+1}) = 3f_{6m+4} - f_{6m+2} = f_{6m+6}.

Suppose v(c3m3)=f6m6v(c_{3m-3}) = f_{6m-6}, v(c3m2)=f6m4v(c_{3m-2}) = f_{6m-4}, v(c3m1)f6m2+1v(c_{3m-1}) \ge f_{6m-2} + 1 and v(c3m)=f6mv(c_{3m}) = f_{6m}. From the equation (9), we have
v(c3m+1)=v(c3m3+k3f6m)v(c3m1)=v(c3m18+3c3m15k3f6m2+3c3m12k6f6m2+k3f6mc3m3)3v(c3m2)=v(k3f6mc3m3)3v(c3m1)=3f6m+f6m63f6m4=f6m+2. \begin{align*} v(c_{3m+1}) &= v(c_{3m}^3 + k^{3f_{6m}}) - v(c_{3m-1}) \\ &= v(c_{3m-1}^8 + 3c_{3m-1}^5 k^{3f_{6m-2}} + 3c_{3m-1}^2 k^{6f_{6m-2}} + k^{3f_{6m}} c_{3m-3}) - 3v(c_{3m-2}) \\ &= v(k^{3f_{6m}} c_{3m-3}) - 3v(c_{3m-1}) = 3f_{6m} + f_{6m-6} - 3f_{6m-4} = f_{6m+2}. \end{align*}
Thus we prove the lemma. \square

From Lemma 5 and Lemma 6, we prove that if 2mcn2^m \mid c_n, then 2m(cn+13+k3f2n+2)2^m \mid (c_{n+1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n+2}}). With Lemma 4, it follows that cn(cn+13+k3f2n+2)c_n \mid (c_{n+1}^3 + k^{3f_{2n+2}}) and cn+2c_{n+2} is a positive integer.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.