Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / NMO Selection Tests for the Junior Balkan Mathematical Olympiad - Second Selection Test /2 of 4

NMO Selection Tests for the Junior Balkan Mathematical Olympiad - Second Selection Test

Number theory Difficulty 6.5 National Olympiad Prove it Romania

Let M≥1M \ge 1 be a real number. Determine all natural numbers nn for which there exist pairwise distinct natural numbers a,b,c>Ma, b, c > M, such that
n=(a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b) n = (a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b)
(where (x,y)(x, y) denotes the greatest common divisor of natural numbers xx and yy).

Solution

Call good a number n∈Nn \in \mathbb{N} for which there exist a,b,c∈N≥1a, b, c \in \mathbb{N}_{\ge 1} such that
n=(a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b).n = (a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b).
We will prove that, regardless of the value of MM, the good numbers are those of the form n=22t(2k+1)n = 2^{2t}(2k+1), where t,k∈Nt, k \in \mathbb{N}, k≥1k \ge 1.
Let k≥1k \ge 1 and p,q,r>Mp, q, r > M three distinct primes such that r>max⁡{kp,kq}r > \max\{kp, kq\}. Considering a=kp,b=kqa = kp, b = kq and c=rc = r, we have (a,b)=k(a, b) = k and (b,c)=(c,a)=1(b, c) = (c, a) = 1, which leads to (a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b)=2k+1(a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b) = 2k+1, so 2k+12k+1 is good.
Let t∈Nt \in \mathbb{N} and nn be a natural number for which there exist a,b,c>Ma, b, c > M, pairwise distinct, such that n=(a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b)n = (a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b). For every t∈Nt \in \mathbb{N}, we have 2ta,2tb,2tc>M2^t a, 2^t b, 2^t c > M and 22t⋅n=(2ta,2tb)⋅(2tb,2tc)+(2tb,2tc)⋅(2tc,2ta)+(2tc,2ta)⋅(2ta,2tb)2^{2t} \cdot n = (2^t a, 2^t b) \cdot (2^t b, 2^t c) + (2^t b, 2^t c) \cdot (2^t c, 2^t a) + (2^t c, 2^t a) \cdot (2^t a, 2^t b), so all the numbers of the form n=22t(2k+1)n = 2^{2t}(2k+1) are good.

Further, we prove that the numbers of the form n=2tn = 2^t or n=22t+1(2k+1)n = 2^{2t+1}(2k+1), where t,k∈Nt, k \in \mathbb{N}, k≥1k \ge 1, are not good, so they don't satisfy the conditions of the problem either.
First, we prove that any good number that is even is actually divisible by 4.
Consider n0n_0 an even number. If n0=(a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b)n_0 = (a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b), then (a,b)(a, b), (b,c)(b, c) and (c,a)(c, a) can't be simultaneously odd. For example, if 2∣(a,b)2 \mid (a, b), then 2∣(b,c)⋅(c,a)2 \mid (b, c) \cdot (c, a), so a,ba, b and cc are even (the other cases are completely similar). It follows that 4∣n04 \mid n_0. Also, the number n04\frac{n_0}{4} is good too, because n04=(a′,b′)⋅(b′,c′)+(b′,c′)⋅(c′,a′)+(c′,a′)⋅(a′,b′)\frac{n_0}{4} = (a', b') \cdot (b', c') + (b', c') \cdot (c', a') + (c', a') \cdot (a', b'), where a′=a2,b′=b2,c′=c2a' = \frac{a}{2}, b' = \frac{b}{2}, c' = \frac{c}{2}.
Suppose, for the sake of contradiction, that there exists t≥2t \ge 2 such that n=2tn = 2^t is good. Consequently, 2t−2,2t−4,2t−6,…2^{t-2}, 2^{t-4}, 2^{t-6}, \dots etc. are also good, so either 1 or 2 should be also good. This is a contradiction, since if a,b,c≥1a, b, c \ge 1, then (a,b)⋅(b,c)+(b,c)⋅(c,a)+(c,a)⋅(a,b)≥3(a, b) \cdot (b, c) + (b, c) \cdot (c, a) + (c, a) \cdot (a, b) \ge 3.
Similarly, if n=22t+1(2k+1)n = 2^{2t+1}(2k+1), with t,k∈Nt, k \in \mathbb{N}, k≥1k \ge 1 is good, then 22t−1(2k+1)2^{2t-1}(2k+1), 22t−3(2k+1),…,2(2k+1)2^{2t-3}(2k+1), \dots, 2(2k+1) are also good, impossible, since 2(2k+1)2(2k+1) is not divisible by 4.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.