Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / United States — Team Selection Test /9 of 40

United States — Team Selection Test

Combinatorics Difficulty 8.2 Shortlist Prove it United States

Let n≥1n \ge 1 be an integer, and let SS be a set of integer pairs (a,b)(a, b) with 1≤a<b≤2n1 \le a < b \le 2^n. Assume ∣S∣>n⋅2n+1|S| > n \cdot 2^{n+1}. Prove that there exist four integers a<b<c<da < b < c < d such that SS contains all three pairs (a,c)(a, c), (b,d)(b, d) and (a,d)(a, d).

Solution

Let pp and qq be integers with 1≤p≤2n1 \le p \le 2^n and 0≤q≤n−10 \le q \le n-1. We say that a pair (a,b)(a, b) has type A(p,q)A(p, q) if a=pa = p and 2q≤b−a<2q+12^q \le b - a < 2^{q+1}, and we say that it has type B(p,q)B(p, q) if b=pb = p and 2q≤b−a<2q+12^q \le b - a < 2^{q+1}. Because there are n2n+1n2^{n+1} total types and ∣S∣>n2n+1|S| > n2^{n+1}, we may find some (a,b)∈S(a, b) \in S such that (a,b)(a, b) is neither
* the pair of type A(a,q)A(a, q) in SS with the smallest possible value of bb, nor
* the pair of type B(b,q)B(b, q) in SS with the largest possible value of aa.
Therefore, there exists (a,b′)∈S(a, b') \in S of type A(a,q)A(a, q) with b′<bb' < b; note that b′−a≥2qb' - a \ge 2^q. Similarly, there exists (a′,b)∈S(a', b) \in S of type B(b,q)B(b, q) with a<a′a < a'; note that b−a′≥2qb - a' \ge 2^q. Adding the two inequalities yields
2q+1≤b′−a+b−a′<b′−a′+2q+1, 2^{q+1} \le b' - a + b - a' < b' - a' + 2^{q+1},
hence a′<b′a' < b'. Then, we have a<a′<b′<ba < a' < b' < b, where SS contains the three pairs (a,b)(a, b), (a,b′)(a, b'), and (a′,b)(a', b), as needed.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.