Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /68 of 69

, 2011

Geometry Difficulty 7.1 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it South Africa

In the plane there are 20122012 congruent triangles of area 11 which all have the same orientation. Each of these triangles contains the centroids of all the other triangles.

a. Show that the intersection of the 20122012 triangles is a triangle similar to them with area at least 19\frac{1}{9}.

b. Show that the area of the union of these triangles is less than 229\frac{22}{9}.

Solution

a.
Let AsBsCsA_sB_sC_s be the given triangles, with s{1,2,,2012}s \in \{1, 2, \dots, 2012\} and let {XYZ}\{XYZ\} stand for the half-plane with the boundary line XYXY and interior point ZZ. Each of the triangles is the intersection of the three half-planes {AsBsCs}\{A_sB_sC_s\}, {BsCsAs}\{B_sC_sA_s\} and {CsAsBs}\{C_sA_sB_s\}, hence the intersection of all the triangles is the intersection of all such half-planes. Since the half-planes {AsBsCs}\{A_sB_sC_s\}, 1s20121 \le s \le 2012 differ only by translation, their intersection is the half-plane {AiBiCi}\{A_iB_iC_i\} for a certain ii. Similarly, the intersection of the half-planes {BsCsAs}\{B_sC_sA_s\} is the half-plane {BjCjAj}\{B_jC_jA_j\} for some jj and the intersection of the half-planes {CsAsBs}\{C_sA_sB_s\} is the half-plane {CkAkBk}\{C_kA_kB_k\} for some kk. Hence the intersection of all the half-planes is the intersection of the three half-planes {AiBiCi}\{A_iB_iC_i\}, {BjCjAj}\{B_jC_jA_j\} and {CkAkBk}\{C_kA_kB_k\}, which is a triangle ABCABC which is similar to the original triangles, since its sides are parallel to the sides of the original triangles. Let the coefficient of similarity be λ\lambda. Clearly 0<λ10 < \lambda \le 1; we wish to show that λ13\lambda \ge \frac{1}{3}.

Let vv be the altitude from the vertex CiC_i to the side AiBiA_iB_i in triangle AiBiCiA_iB_iC_i. Since the line AiBiA_iB_i coincides with the line ABAB, the distance of the centroid GiG_i of triangle AiBiCiA_iB_iC_i from the line ABAB equals 13v\frac{1}{3}v. Since every triangle contains the centroid of all the triangles, triangle ABCABC contains all of them as well, and in particular, ABCABC contains the centroid GiG_i, which means that the distance between CC and the line ABAB is at least 13v\frac{1}{3}v. Comparing the altitudes from the vertices CiC_i and CC in the similar triangles AiBiCiA_iB_iC_i and ABCABC, we thus obtain immediately that λ13\lambda \ge \frac{1}{3}, and so the area of ABCABC is at least 19\frac{1}{9}.

b.
Let AsBsCsA_sB_sC_s be any one of the given triangles. The triangle ABCABC is contained in it, and so the vertex AsA_s lies in the half-plane {BCA}\{BCA\} at a distance at most vv from the line BCBC, where vv is the length of the altitude from the vertex AsA_s in triangle AsBsCsA_sB_sC_s. On the other hand, the distance of the side BsCsB_sC_s from AA is also at most vv. Since the triangle ABCABC contains centroids of all the given triangles, the distance between the side BsCsB_sC_s and BCBC cannot exceed 13v\frac{1}{3}v. The distance of the vertex AA from the side BCBC equals λv\lambda v, so altogether the distance between the parallel lines BCBC and BsCsB_sC_s is at most min{1/3,1λ}v\min\{1/3, 1-\lambda\} \cdot v. All the given triangles thus lie in the belt bounded by the two parallel lines a0a_0 and a1a_1 parallel to BCBC whose distance from BCBC is vv and min{1/3,1λ}v\min\{1/3, 1-\lambda\} \cdot v, respectively. A similar assertion clearly holds for the other two sides ACAC and ABAB, so the union of the 20122012 triangles lie in the intersection of the three belts.

Figure 1

We now distinguish two cases, depending on the value of min{1/3,1λ}\min\{1/3, 1-\lambda\}.

If 13λ<23\frac{1}{3} \le \lambda < \frac{2}{3}, then the intersection of the belts is a hexagon which is obtained from the triangle TT determined by the triple of lines (a1,b1,c1)(a_1, b_1, c_1) upon removing the three small triangles Ta,TbT_a, T_b and TcT_c determined by the triples of lines (a0,b1,c1)(a_0, b_1, c_1), (a1,b0,c1)(a_1, b_0, c_1) and (a1,b1,c0)(a_1, b_1, c_0) respectively. From the way the lines a0,b0,c0,a1,b1,c1a_0, b_0, c_0, a_1, b_1, c_1 are defined, it follows that the TT is similar to the given triangles with coefficient of similarity equal to 1+λ1 + \lambda and the triangles Ta,Tb,TcT_a, T_b, T_c are also similar to the given triangles with coefficient of similarity λ13\lambda - \frac{1}{3}.

The area of the hexagon is therefore given by (recalling that λ<23\lambda < \frac{2}{3})
S=(1+λ)23(λ13)2=832(λ1)2<8329=229. S = (1 + \lambda)^2 - 3 \left( \lambda - \frac{1}{3} \right)^2 = \frac{8}{3} - 2(\lambda - 1)^2 < \frac{8}{3} - \frac{2}{9} = \frac{22}{9}.

Figure 2

If 23λ1\frac{2}{3} \le \lambda \le 1, then the intersection of the three belts is again a hexagon, and the corresponding triangle TT is similar to the given triangles with coefficient of similarity 32λ3 - 2\lambda, and the triangles Ta,Tb,TcT_a, T_b, T_c have coefficients of similarity 1λ1 - \lambda. The area of the hexagon in this case is given by
(32λ)23(1λ)2=(λ3)234993=229, (3 - 2\lambda)^2 - 3(1 - \lambda)^2 = (\lambda - 3)^2 - 3 \le \frac{49}{9} - 3 = \frac{22}{9},
with equality if λ=23\lambda = \frac{2}{3}.

Figure 3

However, since we only start with a finite number of triangles, the side a0a_0 of the hexagon can only contain a finite number of vertices of the given triangles (and cannot coincide with one of these triangles' sides), and so the entire area of the hexagon cannot be covered with only finitely many of these triangles, hence the inequality is strict.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.