Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /68 of 121

Algebra Difficulty 6.2 National Olympiad Prove it India

Problem:
Let p,q,rp, q, r be positive real numbers, not all equal, such that some two of the equations
px2+2qx+r=0,qx2+2rx+p=0,rx2+2px+q=0 p x^{2}+2 q x+r=0, \quad q x^{2}+2 r x+p=0, \quad r x^{2}+2 p x+q=0
have a common root, say α\alpha. Prove that
(a) α\alpha is real and negative; and
(b) the third equation has non-real roots.

Solution

Solution:
Consider the discriminants of the three equations
px2+2qx+r=0qx2+2rx+p=0rx2+2px+q=0 \begin{array}{r} p x^{2}+2 q x+r=0 \\ q x^{2}+2 r x+p=0 \\ r x^{2}+2 p x+q=0 \end{array}
Let us denote them by D1,D2,D3D_{1}, D_{2}, D_{3} respectively. Then we have
D1=4(q2rp),D2=4(r2pq),D3=4(p2qr) D_{1}=4\left(q^{2}-r p\right), \quad D_{2}=4\left(r^{2}-p q\right), \quad D_{3}=4\left(p^{2}-q r\right)
We observe that
D1+D2+D3=4(p2+q2+r2pqqrrp)=2{(pq)2+(qr)2+(rp)2}>0 \begin{aligned} D_{1}+D_{2}+D_{3} & =4\left(p^{2}+q^{2}+r^{2}-p q-q r-r p\right) \\ & =2\left\{(p-q)^{2}+(q-r)^{2}+(r-p)^{2}\right\}>0 \end{aligned}
since p,q,rp, q, r are not all equal. Hence at least one of D1,D2,D3D_{1}, D_{2}, D_{3} must be positive. We may assume D1>0D_{1}>0.
Suppose D2<0D_{2}<0 and D3<0D_{3}<0. In this case both the equations (2) and (3) have only non-real roots and equation (1) has only real roots. Hence the common root α\alpha must be between (2) and (3). But then αˉ\bar{\alpha} is the other root of both (2) and (3). Hence it follows that (2) and (3) have same set of roots. This implies that
qr=rp=pq \frac{q}{r}=\frac{r}{p}=\frac{p}{q}
Thus p=q=rp=q=r contradicting the given condition. Hence both D2D_{2} and D3D_{3} cannot be negative. We may assume D20D_{2} \geq 0. Thus we have
q2rp>0,r2pq0 q^{2}-r p>0, \quad r^{2}-p q \geq 0
These two give
q2r2>p2qr q^{2} r^{2}>p^{2} q r
since p,q,rp, q, r are all positive. Hence we obtain qr>p2q r>p^{2} or D3<0D_{3}<0. We conclude that the common root must be between equations (1) and (2).
Thus
pα2+2qα+r=0qα2+2rα+p=0 \begin{aligned} & p \alpha^{2}+2 q \alpha+r=0 \\ & q \alpha^{2}+2 r \alpha+p=0 \end{aligned}
Eliminating α2\alpha^{2}, we obtain
2(q2pr)α=p2qr 2\left(q^{2}-p r\right) \alpha=p^{2}-q r
Since q2pr>0q^{2}-p r>0 and p2qr<0p^{2}-q r<0, we conclude that α<0\alpha<0.
The condition p2qr<0p^{2}-q r<0 implies that the equation (3) has only non-real roots.

Alternately one can argue as follows. Suppose α\alpha is a common root of two equations, say, (1) and (2). If α\alpha is non-real, then αˉ\bar{\alpha} is also a root of both (1) and (2). Hence the coefficients of (1) and (2) are proportional. This forces p=q=rp=q=r, a contradiction. Hence the common root between any two equations cannot be non-real. Looking at the coefficients, we conclude that the common root α\alpha must be negative. If (1) and (2) have common root α\alpha, then q2rpq^{2} \geq r p and r2pqr^{2} \geq p q. Here at least one inequality is strict for q2=prq^{2}=p r and r2=pqr^{2}=p q forces p=q=rp=q=r. Hence q2r2>p2qrq^{2} r^{2}>p^{2} q r. This gives p2<qrp^{2}<q r and hence (3) has non-real roots.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.