Problem:
Let be positive real numbers, not all equal, such that some two of the equations
have a common root, say . Prove that
(a) is real and negative; and
(b) the third equation has non-real roots.
Solution
Solution:
Consider the discriminants of the three equations
Let us denote them by respectively. Then we have
We observe that
since are not all equal. Hence at least one of must be positive. We may assume .
Suppose and . In this case both the equations (2) and (3) have only non-real roots and equation (1) has only real roots. Hence the common root must be between (2) and (3). But then is the other root of both (2) and (3). Hence it follows that (2) and (3) have same set of roots. This implies that
Thus contradicting the given condition. Hence both and cannot be negative. We may assume . Thus we have
These two give
since are all positive. Hence we obtain or . We conclude that the common root must be between equations (1) and (2).
Thus
Eliminating , we obtain
Since and , we conclude that .
The condition implies that the equation (3) has only non-real roots.
Alternately one can argue as follows. Suppose is a common root of two equations, say, (1) and (2). If is non-real, then is also a root of both (1) and (2). Hence the coefficients of (1) and (2) are proportional. This forces , a contradiction. Hence the common root between any two equations cannot be non-real. Looking at the coefficients, we conclude that the common root must be negative. If (1) and (2) have common root , then and . Here at least one inequality is strict for and forces . Hence . This gives and hence (3) has non-real roots.