Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / Romanian Mathematical Olympiad /214 of 275

Romanian Mathematical Olympiad

Algebra Difficulty 6.3 National Olympiad Prove it Romania

a) Show that if a,b>1a, b > 1 are distinct real numbers then
log⁡a(log⁡ab)>log⁡b(log⁡ab). \log_a(\log_a b) > \log_b(\log_a b).

b) Let a1>a2>⋯>an>1a_1 > a_2 > \dots > a_n > 1 be real numbers, n≥2n \ge 2. Prove that
log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a2)+log⁡a2(log⁡a2(a3)+⋯+log⁡an−1(log⁡an−1(an)+log⁡an(log⁡an(a1))))>0. \log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \log_{a_2}(\log_{a_2}(a_3) + \dots + \log_{a_{n-1}}(\log_{a_{n-1}}(a_n) + \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1)))) > 0.

Solution

a) For a<ba < b, log⁡a(log⁡ab)=(log⁡ab)(log⁡b(log⁡ab))>log⁡b(log⁡ab)\log_a(\log_a b) = (\log_a b)(\log_b(\log_a b)) > \log_b(\log_a b) because log⁡b(log⁡ab)>0\log_b(\log_a b) > 0 and log⁡ab>1\log_a b > 1.
For a>ba > b, the claim is reached from log⁡ab<1\log_a b < 1 and log⁡b(log⁡ab)<0\log_b(\log_a b) < 0.

b) Induct on nn. For n=2n = 2,
log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a2)+log⁡a2(log⁡a2(a1)))>log⁡a2(log⁡a1(a2)+log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a1)))=log⁡a2(1)=0. \log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \log_{a_2}(\log_{a_2}(a_1))) > \log_{a_2}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_1))) = \log_{a_2}(1) = 0.
Assume now that the claim holds for some nn and consider the numbers a1>a2>⋯>an+1>1a_1 > a_2 > \dots > a_{n+1} > 1. Then
log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a2)+⋯+log⁡an(log⁡an(an+1)+log⁡an+1(log⁡an+1(a1)))=log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a2)+⋯+log⁡an−1(log⁡an−1(an)+log⁡an(log⁡an(a1)))+log⁡a1(log⁡a1(a2)+⋯+log⁡an−1(log⁡an−1(an)+log⁡an(log⁡an(a1))=>log⁡an+1(log⁡an(an+1)+log⁡an+1(log⁡an+1(a1))−log⁡an(log⁡an(a1))>>log⁡an+1(log⁡an(an+1)+log⁡an+1(log⁡an+1(a1))−log⁡an(log⁡an(a1))==log⁡an+1(log⁡an(a1)−log⁡an(log⁡an(a1)))>0, \begin{align*} & \log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \dots + \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_{n+1}) + \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_{n+1}}(a_1))) = \\ & \qquad \log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \dots + \log_{a_{n-1}}(\log_{a_{n-1}}(a_n) + \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1))) + \\ & \qquad \phantom{\log_{a_1}(\log_{a_1}(a_2) + \dots + \log_{a_{n-1}}(\log_{a_{n-1}}(a_n) + \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1)) =} \\ & > \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_n}(a_{n+1}) + \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_{n+1}}(a_1)) - \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1)) > \\ & \qquad \phantom{> \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_n}(a_{n+1}) + \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_{n+1}}(a_1)) - \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1)) =} \\ & = \log_{a_{n+1}}(\log_{a_n}(a_1) - \log_{a_n}(\log_{a_n}(a_1))) > 0, \end{align*}
because log⁡ana1>1\log_{a_n} a_1 > 1 and an+1<ana_{n+1} < a_n.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.