Problem:
Determine if there exist positive integers such that , , , and
Problem:
Determine if there exist positive integers such that , , , and
Solution:
There do not exist such positive integers. Assume for a contradiction that there do, however. We may assume , so that . Since we have equality between a power of and a power of , is a rational power of . We write , where we know that is a rational number. Then we may rewrite the power tower (using ) as
On the other hand, we know that this is equal to the power tower of 's in the given equation, so removing the bottom gives
In particular, this tells us that is a rational power of , for some nonnegative rational number . Substituting and again removing the bottom gives
Observe that the right side is plus a rational power of (simply if ). Now consider the possibilities for this power . If , then and the right side of (2) is less than 1, an impossibility. So either is irrational (again impossible) or it is the th root of a th power, which is necessarily a positive integer. Then is also an integer, namely, the difference between the tower of 's on the left and another power of . Dividing both sides of (2) by indicates that is at least times the tower of 's, which is certainly larger than a power tower of 's. But then is larger than a power tower of 's, and clearly the right side of (2) is even larger than this, so we have a contradiction.