Find all triples of real numbers such that
holds for all .
, 2021
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
The triples we are looking for have the forms , , , where .
If then for all . Since and , we must have and for any . Thus , which clearly works.
Now, suppose that . Plugging in we find . Therefore and . This means that and for some integers and , i.e. and .
Note that . Indeed, otherwise for all , but has negative values. For similar reason . We shall prove that . Suppose otherwise. Assume without loss of generality that . Plug in . We obtain . Note that . Moreover, if then is nonnegative, yielding a contradiction. Therefore we have . This leads to . This means: . Clearly, such triples work.
Solution 2
Applying the operator two times and four times we obtain and , respectively. Plugging in we obtain and . Therefore
which yields . Therefore . From we obtain . Therefore and we check directly that all such triples work.