Let , , be distinct nonzero real numbers. If the equations , and have a common root, prove that at least one of these equations has three real roots (not necessarily distinct).
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
Let the common root be . Adding the three equations, we get
If , then becomes . Similarly, becomes . As , , are distinct, we obtain . After expansion and regrouping the terms, this becomes
This is a contradiction since , , are distinct.
Therefore, we must have . In that case, it is obvious that is the common root. As , , are nonzero, there are two possible cases.
If two of , , are positive, say , , we consider . Since and when , there is at least one negative root of . As is another root and a cubic polynomial cannot have exactly two real roots, the equation must have exactly three real roots.
Similarly, if two of , , are negative, say , , then the above argument shows has three real roots. This shows also has three real roots.
Solution 2
Let be the common root. Adding the three equations , and , we get .
If , then becomes . Similarly, becomes . As , , are distinct, the two equations combine to give , i.e. , which yields the contradiction .
Therefore, we must have . Then it is obvious that is the common root. As , , are nonzero, there are two possible cases.
Case 1: Two of , , are positive, say and . Consider . Since and is negative for sufficiently small , there is at least one negative root of . As is also a root, has at least two real roots and hence exactly three real roots (since complex roots occur in pairs).
Case 2: Two of , , are negative, say and . Then the same argument shows that the polynomial has three real zeros, and the same is clearly true for .