Suppose ABC is an isosceles triangle with b=c. Show that 4bc>a2. Give an example of a right-angled triangle with hypotenuse a in which this inequality fails.
Solution
By the triangle inequality, a<b+c, hence a<2b, using b=c. Therefore a2<4bc, as required.
If x>1, and a=x2+1, b=2x, c=x2−1, then b2+c2=4x2+(x4−2x2+1)=x4+2x2+1=a2, and so a, b, c are side lengths of a right-angled triangle with hypotenuse a. Then a2−4bc=(x2+1)2−8x(x2−1)=x4−8x3+2x2+8x+1=x3(x−8)+2x2+8x+1. Clearly, the polynomial x3(x−8)+2x2+8x+1 is positive if x is large enough, e.g., any x≥8 will do. So, as long as x≥8 we have a right-angled triangle in which a2>4bc.
Alternatively, we may find such examples as follows. If a is the length of the hypotenuse of the right-angled triangle ABC, its area (ABC) is equal to bc/2. Hence, the desired inequality a2>4bc is equivalent to a2>8(ABC). If h is the height of triangle ABC on the hypotenuse a, then (ABC) = ah/2 and the desired inequality becomes a>4h. In the diagram below, this means that A should be on the semicircle but not above the dashed line. To make this more explicit, let the foot of the altitude from A divide the hypotenuse into segments of length p and q, and recall that h2=pq=p(a−p). Thus, we want a2>16h2=16p(a−p), i.e. a2−16pa+16p2>0. This is equivalent to (pa−8)2>48, i.e. pa−8>43. As 0<p<a in our case, given a we can choose any p such that 0<p<42−3or42+3<p<a. Because c2=p2+h2=p(p+q)=ap and b2=aq=a(a−p), the value of p determines b=a2−ap and c=ap for any given a. For example, with a=41 and p=81/41, we obtain b=40 and c=9. In this example, a2=1681>1440=4bc.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.