a.
Let x′, y′, z′ and S′ be obtained from x, y, z and S by replacing a, b, c by a+t, b+t, c+t, respectively. So
x′=(a+t)+(b+t)+(c+t)=x+3t,
y′=(a+t)2+(b+t)2+(c+t)2=(a2+b2+c2)+2(a+b+c)t+3t2=y+2xt+3t2,
z′=(a+t)3+(b+t)3+(c+t)3=(a3+b3+c3)+3(a2+b2+c2)t+3(a+b+c)t2+3t3=z+3yt+3xt2+3t3. Hence
S′=2x′3−9x′y′+9z′=2(x+3t)3−9(x+3t)(y+2xt+3t2)+9(z+3yt+3xt2+3t3)=2x3−9xy+9z=S(All other terms cancel.)
b.
If we let T=3y−x2 and T′=3y′−x′2, we obtain
T=3(a2+b2+c2)−(a+b+c)2=2(a2+b2+c2−ab−ac−bc)=(a−b)2+(b−c)2+(c−a)2=(a′−b′)2+(b′−c′)2+(c′−a′)2=T′.
Version A. We take t=−c and so it suffices to prove that T3−2S2≥0 in the case c=0, where we get T=3(a2+b2)−(a+b)2=2(a2−ab+b2) and
S=2(a+b)3−9(a+b)(a2+b2)+9(a3+b3)=2a3−3a2b−3ab2+2b3=2(a3+b3)−3ab(a+b)=(a+b)(2(a2−ab+b2)−3ab).Now
T3−2S2=8(a2−ab+b2)3−2(a+b)2(2(a2−ab+b2)−3ab)2=8(a2−ab+b2)3−8(a+b)2(a2−ab+b2)2+24ab(a+b)2(a2−ab+b2)−18a2b2(a+b)2=−24ab(a2−ab+b2)2+24ab(a+b)2(a2−ab+b2)−18a2b2(a+b)2=24ab(a2−ab+b2)((a+b)2−(a2−ab+b2))−18a2b2(a+b)2=72a2b2(a2−ab+b2)−18a2b2(a2+2ab+b2)=6a2b2(12(a2+b2)−12ab−3(a2+b2)−6ab)=54a2b2(a−b)2≥0.This completes the proof.
Version B. By choosing t=−(a+b+c)/3 we achieve that x vanishes. In this case, T=3y and S=9z and c=−(a+b). We obtain
yz=a2+b2+(a+b)2=2(a2+ab+b2)=a3+b3−(a+b)3=−3ab(a+b)
and so T=6(a2+ab+b2) and S=−27ab(a+b). Hence,
(T3−2S2)/54=4(a2+ab+b2)3−27(ab(a+b))2.
(T3−2S2)/54=4(a2+a+1)3−27(a(a+1))2.
As this vanishes for a=1, we rewrite it in terms of multiples of a−1. Because a(a+1)=(a−1)(a+2)+2 and a2+a+1=(a−1)(a+2)+3, we see that the above vanishes for a=−2, too. Abbreviating P=(a−1)(a+2), we get
(T3−2S2)/54=4(P+3)3−27(P+2)2=4(P3+9P2+27P+27)−27(P2+4P+4)=4P3+9P2=P2(4P+9)=(a−1)2(a+2)2(4(a−1)(a+2)+9)=(a−1)2(a+2)2(4a2+4a+1)=(a−1)2(a+2)2(2a+1)2≥0.
We now set P=a2+ab+b2 and Q=3a2. We have 27(ab(a+b))2=27a2(R−a2)2=3a2(3R−3a2)2=Q(3R−Q)2, and so
(T3−2S2)/54=4R3−Q(3R−Q)2.
This vanishes for Q=R, so we write 3R−Q=2R+(R−Q) and simplify:
4R3−Q(2R+(R−Q))2=4R3−4R2Q−4QR(R−Q)−Q(R−Q)2=4R2(R−Q)−(4QR+Q(R−Q))(R−Q)=(R−Q)(4R2−4QR−Q(R−Q))=(R−Q)(4R(R−Q)−Q(R−Q))=(R−Q)2(4R−Q)=(R−Q)2(a2+4ab+4b2)=(R−Q)2(a+2b)2≥0.
Remark. We may trace back our steps and write a/b for a and multiply by b6. This translates (a−1)2(a+2)2(2a+1)2 into (a−b)2(a+2b)2(2a+b)2. Writing −c for a+b in the last two brackets, we get (a−b)2(b−c)2(a−c)2, which is the discriminant of the cubic (X−a)(X−b)(X−c).