Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /61 of 61

Combinatorics Difficulty 7.6 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Ibero-American Mathematical Olympiad

Problem:

A game is played on a 2001×20012001 \times 2001 board as follows. The first player's piece is the policeman, the second player's piece is the robber. Each piece can move one square south, one square east or one square northwest. In addition, the policeman (but not the robber) can move from the bottom right to the top left square in a single move. The policeman starts in the central square, and the robber starts one square diagonally northeast of the policeman. If the policeman moves onto the same square as the robber, then the robber is captured and the first player wins. However, the robber may move onto the same square as the policeman without being captured (and play continues). Show that the robber can avoid capture for at least 1000010000 moves, but that the policeman can ultimately capture the robber.

Solution

Solution:

Color the squares with three colors as follows:

```
0 1 2 0 1 2 0 \ldots 2
1 2 0 1 2 0 1 \cdots 0
2 0 1 2 0 1 2 \cdots 1
```

The middle square is color 22 (moving 999+1999+1 squares EE from the top left increases the color by 11, then moving 999+1 S999+1~S increases it by another 11) and the square immediately NENE of it is also 22. So both PP and RR start on color 22. Note that any move increases the color by 11 mod 33, except for PP's special move which changes the color from 11 to 00.

Until PP has made this move, after each move of PP, PP's color is always 11 more than RR's color (mod3)(\bmod 3), so PP cannot win (irrespective of the moves made by either player). Immediately after he makes the special move for the first time, PP is on color 00 and RR is on color 11, so immediately after his move PP's color is now 11 less than RR's color mod 33. Again PP cannot win. But after PP has made the special move for the second time, PP's color is the same as RR's (mod 33) immediately after PP's move.

Note that it takes PP at least 20012001 moves to complete his special move for the first time and at least 60026002 moves (in total) to complete his special move for the second time. This solves the first part of the question. Suppose RR just moves down to the bottom right and then moves in small circles (one move NWNW, one move SS, one move EE) waiting for PP. It takes PP at least 6002+39996002 + 3999 (moving from top left to the capture square, one square short of the bottom right) =10001= 10001 to capture him, so RR makes at least 1000010000 moves before being captured.

We claim that PP wins if he can get into any of the positions shown below relative to RR, with RR to move ()(*) :

```
X P X X X
P xXP\quad x \quad X \quad P \quad x
x xRx\quad x \quad R \quad x \quad x
X PxX\quad P \quad x \quad X \quad P
x x x \quad x
```

It follows that PP can also win from the four positions below ()(**) :

```
X X X P X X X
x xxxxx\quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x
X x x x x x x
P X X RxX\quad R \quad x \quad X \quad P
x xxxxx\quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x
x xxxxx\quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x \quad x
x xxPxx\quad x \quad x \quad P \quad x \quad x \quad x
```

For in each case at least one of RR's possible moves allow PP to move immediately into one of the winning positions at ()(*). But RR can only make the other moves a limited number of times before running into the border. [That is obvious if the other two moves are EE and SS. If they are NWNW and EE, then every NWNW move takes RR closer to the top border, but his total number of EE moves can never exceed his total number of NWNW moves by more than 20002000 because of the right border. Similarly, for NWNW and SS.]

Now let dd be the number of rows plus the number of columns that RR and PP are apart. It is easy to check that the positions in ()(*) and ()(**) represent the only possibilities for d=2d=2 and 33. We show that PP can always get to d=2d=2 or 33. For PP can always copy RR's move, so he can certainly move so that dd never increases. But one of RR's moves will always allow PP to decrease dd by 11 or 22. There are three cases to consider:

Case 1. If PP is east of RR and RR moves EE, then PP moving NWNW will decrease dd by 11 or 22. That is not possible if PP is in the top row, but then moving SS will decrease dd by 22 unless RR is also in the top row. If both are in the top row, then PP moves SS. Now after RR's next move, PP moves NWNW which reduces dd by 22.

Case 2. If PP is south of RR and RR moves SS, then a similar argument shows that PP can always decrease dd by 11 or 22 in one or two moves.

Case 3. If PP is not south or east of RR, and RR moves NWNW, then PP can always decrease dd by 11 or 22 by moving SS or EE.

But repeated decreases by 11 or 22 must bring dd ultimately to 22 or 33 and hence to one of ()(*) or ()(**). So PP can always win.

It remains to prove the claim that ()(*) are winning positions. The reason is that in each case RR has one move blocked off, so must make one of the other two. PP then copies RR's move, so next turn RR has the same move blocked off. Repeated use of the other two moves will bring him ultimately to one of the sides.

We start with the easiest case: in the two following positions. RR cannot move to zz, so he must move east or south on each move. Hence he will (after at most 40004000 moves) reach the bottom right corner. He then loses moving out of it.

```
X P X
P z x
x X R
```

The other cases of ()(*) are slightly more complicated. Starting from either of the two positions below, we show that RR must eventually reach the extreme left column.

```
w xP\quad x \quad P \quad x
x Rz\quad R \quad z \quad x
x y x P
```

RR cannot move to zz, so he can only make NWNW and SS moves. But his total number of SS moves can never exceed his total number of NWNW moves by more than 20002000 because he cannot move off the bottom of the board, so he must eventually reach the extreme left column. [If he reaches the bottom row at yy, then PP can always move to zz to preserve the configuration. If RR reaches the top row by moving to ww, then PP can always move to zz to preserve the configuration.]

Having reached the extreme left column he is forced to move south. Eventually moving to yy will take him to the corner. PP then moves to zz and RR is captured on his next move.

The final case to consider is the two positions below. RR cannot move to zz, so must move EE or NWNW. A similar argument to the previous case shows that he must eventually reach the top row. Having reached it at ww, PP moves to zz. So RR is forced to move right along the top row. When he reaches the corner at yy, PP moves to zz and RR is captured when he moves out of the corner.

```
W x x
x R y
P z x
X X P
```

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.