Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / IMO Shortlist /17 of 365

IMO Shortlist

Algebra Difficulty 7.6 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it IMO

A sequence x1,x2,…x_{1}, x_{2}, \ldots is defined by x1=1x_{1}=1 and x2k=−xkx_{2k}=-x_{k}, x2k−1=(−1)k+1xkx_{2k-1}=(-1)^{k+1} x_{k} for all k≥1k \geq 1. Prove that x1+x2+⋯+xn≥0x_{1}+x_{2}+\cdots+x_{n} \geq 0 for all n≥1n \geq 1.

Solutions — 2

Solution 1

We start with some observations. First, from the definition of xix_{i} it follows that for each positive integer kk we have
x4k−3=x2k−1=−x4k−2 and x4k−1=x4k=−x2k=xk. x_{4k-3}=x_{2k-1}=-x_{4k-2} \quad \text{ and } \quad x_{4k-1}=x_{4k}=-x_{2k}=x_{k} .
Hence, denoting Sn=∑i=1nxiS_{n}=\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i}, we have
S4k=∑i=1k((x4k−3+x4k−2)+(x4k−1+x4k))=∑i=1k(0+2xk)=2Sk S_{4k}=\sum_{i=1}^{k}\left(\left(x_{4k-3}+x_{4k-2}\right)+\left(x_{4k-1}+x_{4k}\right)\right)=\sum_{i=1}^{k}\left(0+2x_{k}\right)=2S_{k}
S4k+2=S4k+(x4k+1+x4k+2)=S4k S_{4k+2}=S_{4k}+\left(x_{4k+1}+x_{4k+2}\right)=S_{4k}
Observe also that Sn=∑i=1nxi≡∑i=1n1=n(mod2)S_{n}=\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i} \equiv \sum_{i=1}^{n} 1=n \pmod{2}.
Now we prove by induction on kk that Si≥0S_{i} \geq 0 for all i≤4ki \leq 4k. The base case is valid since x1=x3=x4=1x_{1}=x_{3}=x_{4}=1, x2=−1x_{2}=-1. For the induction step, assume that Si≥0S_{i} \geq 0 for all i≤4ki \leq 4k. Using the relations above, we obtain
S4k+4=2Sk+1≥0,S4k+2=S4k≥0,S4k+3=S4k+2+x4k+3=S4k+2+S4k+42≥0 S_{4k+4}=2S_{k+1} \geq 0, \quad S_{4k+2}=S_{4k} \geq 0, \quad S_{4k+3}=S_{4k+2}+x_{4k+3}=\frac{S_{4k+2}+S_{4k+4}}{2} \geq 0
So, we are left to prove that S4k+1≥0S_{4k+1} \geq 0. If kk is odd, then S4k=2Sk≥0S_{4k}=2S_{k} \geq 0; since kk is odd, SkS_{k} is odd as well, so we have S4k≥2S_{4k} \geq 2 and hence S4k+1=S4k+x4k+1≥1S_{4k+1}=S_{4k}+x_{4k+1} \geq 1.
Conversely, if kk is even, then we have x4k+1=x2k+1=xk+1x_{4k+1}=x_{2k+1}=x_{k+1}, hence S4k+1=S4k+x4k+1=2Sk+xk+1=Sk+Sk+1≥0S_{4k+1}=S_{4k}+x_{4k+1}=2S_{k}+x_{k+1}=S_{k}+S_{k+1} \geq 0. The step is proved.

Solution 2

We will use the notation of SnS_{n} and the relations above from the previous solution.
Assume the contrary and consider the minimal nn such that Sn+1<0S_{n+1}<0; surely n≥1n \geq 1, and from Sn≥0S_{n} \geq 0 we get Sn=0S_{n}=0, xn+1=−1x_{n+1}=-1. Hence, we are especially interested in the set M={n:Sn=0}M=\{n: S_{n}=0\}; our aim is to prove that xn+1=1x_{n+1}=1 whenever n∈Mn \in M thus coming to a contradiction.
For this purpose, we first describe the set MM inductively. We claim that (i) MM consists only of even numbers, (ii) 2∈M2 \in M, and (iii) for every even n≥4n \geq 4 we have n∈M⟺[n/4]∈Mn \in M \Longleftrightarrow [n/4] \in M. Actually, (i) holds since Sn≡n(mod2)S_{n} \equiv n \pmod{2}, (ii) is straightforward, while (iii) follows from the relations S4k+2=S4k=2SkS_{4k+2}=S_{4k}=2S_{k}.
Now, we are left to prove that xn+1=1x_{n+1}=1 if n∈Mn \in M. We use the induction on nn. The base case is n=2n=2, that is, the minimal element of MM; here we have x3=1x_{3}=1, as desired.
For the induction step, consider some 4≤n∈M4 \leq n \in M and let m=[n/4]∈Mm=[n/4] \in M; then mm is even, and xm+1=1x_{m+1}=1 by the induction hypothesis. We prove that xn+1=xm+1=1x_{n+1}=x_{m+1}=1. If n=4mn=4m then we have xn+1=x2m+1=xm+1x_{n+1}=x_{2m+1}=x_{m+1} since mm is even; otherwise, n=4m+2n=4m+2, and xn+1=−x2m+2=xm+1x_{n+1}=-x_{2m+2}=x_{m+1}, as desired. The proof is complete.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.