Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /25 of 87

Geometry Difficulty 5.8 AIME, harder Prove it Serbia

Problem:

Let kk be the circle circumscribed about ABC\triangle ABC, and kak_{a} the circle inscribed opposite vertex AA. The two common tangents of the circles kk and kak_{a} intersect the line BCBC at points PP and QQ. Prove that PAB= QAC\text{PAB= QAC} holds.

(Dušan Đukić)

Solutions — 2

Solution 1

Solution:

Let the internal and external bisectors of angle BACBAC intersect the line BCBC respectively at points DD and (possibly at infinity) D1D_{1}. The common tangents intersect at the center TT of the positive homothety H\mathscr{H} which maps the inscribed circle ωa\omega_{a} to the circumscribed circle Ω\Omega. If TT is a point at infinity, H\mathscr{H} is a translation, and the rest of the proof is the same.

Lemma. Let an arbitrary line pp through D1D_{1} intersect the circle Ω\Omega at points LL and KK. The tangents at LL and KK to Ω\Omega intersect the line BCBC respectively at points PP and QQ. Then PAB= CAQ\text{PAB= CAQ}.

Proof. Denote BAC= , CBA= , ACB= , PAB=x\text{BAC= , CBA= , ACB= , PAB=x} and CAQ=y\text{CAQ=y}.

If D1D_{1} is a point at infinity, the claim is trivial by symmetry. If not, from PBLPLC\triangle PBL \sim \triangle PLC it follows that PBPL=PLPC=LBLC\frac{PB}{PL}=\frac{PL}{PC}=\frac{LB}{LC} and from this PBPC=(LBLC)2\frac{PB}{PC}=\left(\frac{LB}{LC}\right)^{2}. Similarly QBQC=(KBKC)2\frac{QB}{QC}=\left(\frac{KB}{KC}\right)^{2}. Since LBLCKBKC=KLBKLC=D1BD1C=ABAC\frac{LB}{LC} \cdot \frac{KB}{KC}=\frac{|KLB|}{|KLC|}=\frac{D_{1}B}{D_{1}C}=\frac{AB}{AC}, we obtain PBPCQBQC=(ABAC)2\frac{PB}{PC} \cdot \frac{QB}{QC}=\left(\frac{AB}{AC}\right)^{2}. Since PBPC=PBPAPAPC=sinxsinβsinγsin(α+x)\frac{PB}{PC}=\frac{PB}{PA} \cdot \frac{PA}{PC}=\frac{\sin x}{\sin \beta} \cdot \frac{\sin \gamma}{\sin (\alpha+x)} and QBQC=QBQAQAQC=sin(α+y)sinβsinγsiny\frac{QB}{QC}=\frac{QB}{QA} \cdot \frac{QA}{QC}=\frac{\sin (\alpha+y)}{\sin \beta} \cdot \frac{\sin \gamma}{\sin y}, multiplying gives (sinγsinβ)2sin(α+y)/sinysin(α+x)/sinx=(ACAB)2=(sinγsinβ)2\left(\frac{\sin \gamma}{\sin \beta}\right)^{2} \cdot \frac{\sin (\alpha+y) / \sin y}{\sin (\alpha+x) / \sin x}=\left(\frac{AC}{AB}\right)^{2}=\left(\frac{\sin \gamma}{\sin \beta}\right)^{2}, whence sinαctgy+cosα=sin(α+y)siny=sin(α+x)sinx=sinαctgx+cosα\sin \alpha \operatorname{ctg} y+\cos \alpha=\frac{\sin (\alpha+y)}{\sin y}=\frac{\sin (\alpha+x)}{\sin x}=\sin \alpha \operatorname{ctg} x+\cos \alpha, i.e. x=yx=y.

If KK and LL are the points of tangency of the common tangents with Ω\Omega, it remains to show that point D1D_{1} lies on the line KLKL, i.e. on the polar of point TT with respect to Ω\Omega. By the theorem on pole and polar, it suffices to prove that TT lies on the polar dd of point D1D_{1} with respect to Ω\Omega.

Denote by NN the midpoint of the arc BACBAC of the circle Ω\Omega. The image of point DD under the homothety H\mathscr{H} is the intersection SS of the tangents to Ω\Omega at points AA and NN, so point TT lies on the line DSDS. On the other hand, point DD is on the polar dd because the quadruple (B,C;D1,D)\left(B, C ; D_{1}, D\right) is harmonic, and point SS is

Figure 1

also on dd because the polar of point SS with respect to Ω\Omega, which is the line ANAN, contains point D1D_{1}. Therefore, the lines DSDS and dd coincide, which completes the proof.

Solution 2

Solution:

Second solution. Let the common tangents touch the circle Ω\Omega at points KK and LL, where LPLP is the tangent closer to vertex BB. Denote by MM the midpoint of the arc BCBC not containing point AA, and by OO and IaI_{a} respectively the centers of the circumscribed circle and the circle inscribed opposite AA.

Since LPI a =90 + 1 2 LPC\text{LPI a =90 + 1 2 LPC} and LAI a = LAM= 1 2 LOM= 1 2 LPD 1 =90 - 1 2 LPC\text{LAI a = LAM= 1 2 LOM= 1 2 LPD 1 =90 - 1 2 LPC}, it follows that LPI a + LAI a =180\text{LPI a + LAI a =180}, so the quadrilateral ALPIaALPI_{a} is cyclic. Similarly, the quadrilateral AKQIaAKQI_{a} is also cyclic. Now we have PAI a = PLI a = QKI a = QAI a\text{PAI a = PLI a = QKI a = QAI a}, since the angles PLIaPLI_{a} and QKIaQKI_{a} are symmetric with respect to the line OIaOI_{a}, and from this it follows that PAB= QAC\text{PAB= QAC}.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from sr; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.