Problem:
At the beginning, a positive integer is written on a board. If a number is written on the board, one may write down the numbers and . At some point the number 2008 also appears on the board. Prove that it was there from the beginning.
Problem:
At the beginning, a positive integer is written on a board. If a number is written on the board, one may write down the numbers and . At some point the number 2008 also appears on the board. Prove that it was there from the beginning.
Solution:
Sketch of solution: Initially the number is written on the board. The transition from to or shall be called a transformation. All numbers on the board are positive.
1st variant:
From the number , after transformations one always obtains numbers of the form with an integer (proof by complete induction on ). So if 2008 appears on the board at some point, there exist and with , i.e. . Since the second factor is coprime to 2009 (as 2008 and are coprime to 2009), it follows that .
2nd variant:
On a sheet of paper, write for each number on the board the number . At some point 1 appears on the sheet. A transformation of a number on the board maps a number on the sheet to or . So if the initial number on the sheet is not an integer or not coprime to 2009, then integers, or numbers coprime to 2009, can never arise from it. Hence is an integer and coprime to 2009. Since also divides 2009, it follows that and .
3rd variant:
Every transformation maps the reduced rational number to the reduced number , where are positive integers and . Initially one has the reduced representation , at the end , so there exists with . Since 2009 is odd, it follows that and .
4th variant:
Form the sequence of numbers from numbers on the board, where for arises from by one of the two transformations. From one can uniquely reconstruct , since for all we have: , . By induction on for one shows that with and . Thus is an integer (with value 2008) exactly when , i.e. when .