Let be a positive integer. A positive real number is written in each unit square of a grid, so that the sum of the two numbers in each column is . Suppose that, regardless of the numbers written, we could always delete one number from each column so that the sum of the remaining numbers in each row is at most . What is the smallest possible value of ?
(Battsengel B.)
Solution
The minimum value of is
We observe that if the grid is given as below, the value of is not less than .
Let us show that regardless of the numbers written in the grid, we can delete one number from each column, totally numbers, so that the sum of the remaining numbers in each row is at most . Let be the numbers in the first row with sum and let be the numbers in the second row with sum .
Lemma. If and , then .
Proof. From the first condition we get that
Since
it follows that . Similarly, . Since , we get that
Case: . Suppose that . Then and
Hence , which contradicts (1).
Case: . Suppose that . Thus . Similarly to the previous case we get that
which contradicts (1).
Let be the minimum satisfying and let be the minimum satisfying . Then by the lemma . Because of the choice of and , it follows that and . This shows that we can delete numbers from the first row and numbers from the second row so that the sum of the remaining numbers in each row is at most . This completes the proof.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.