Suppose , with , are positive integers arranged in order around a circle so that the sum of the neighbors of each is a multiple of itself, i.e., the fraction
is an integer, where and . Prove that the sum of these multiples satisfies the inequalities
Solution
Solution: The left-hand inequality can be easily proved by A.M. G.M., for example:
Below we deal with the right-hand inequality. In fact, the assumption is not so important; we will prove it for all positive integers . We denote the middle sum by , and what we need to prove is .
When , the left and right neighbors of are itself. Therefore
When , from the given conditions we know , i.e., . Similarly we get . Multiplying these two equations on both sides and canceling the common factor , we know . Since are positive integers, we have
Therefore or , which is of course less than .
Now consider the case . Without loss of generality, we may assume that is the largest among . Then
So or ; when , the three numbers must be equal, and . Thus when are not all equal, we have . Writing out the equations, we get
From the first and third equations, we know . Similarly, from the second and third equations, we know . This is exactly the same as the case , and we can obtain
Hence or , both of which are less than . This concludes the case .
Now consider the general case . If among these 's, the largest number appears consecutively 2 or more times, then all the numbers must be equal. This is because if the 's are not all equal, then there will always be some at one end such that one of its neighbors is the largest number while the other neighbor is a positive integer strictly less than , so the sum of the left and right neighbors cannot possibly be divisible by (since the sum lies strictly between and ). So under this assumption, .
In the case where the largest numbers among the 's all appear in isolation, let be one of these largest numbers. As in the case , we can deduce that
The equations obtained from the two neighbors on either side are
Combining with (1), we get
(Note that from the maximality of , we know that the two neighboring multiples are both greater than 1.) Observe: when is deleted, the two neighbors of become and ; similarly, the two neighbors of become and . This argument tells us that when one of the largest numbers is removed, the remaining numbers still satisfy the conditions of the problem (i.e., the sum of the left and right neighbors is a multiple of itself), and among the multiples, besides the one 1 (namely ) being removed, the two neighboring multiples (namely and ) each also decrease by 1. Therefore we obtain . Since we have already proved the cases , the result for general positive integers follows by mathematical induction. Q.E.D.