Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /15 of 31

Combinatorics Difficulty 6.5 National Olympiad Prove it Italy

Problem:

A welder has metal rods of length 2, and wants to build a grid consisting of n×nn \times n unit squares of side 1 (example 5×55 \times 5 alongside). He is allowed to saw the rods in half and weld them together, but without overlapping or crossing them. What is the minimum number of rods that must be sawed in order to obtain the grid?

Figure 1

Solution

Solution:

If nn is odd, in every row there is a rod of length 1 and therefore the number of rods of length 1 is at least 2(n+1)2(n+1); hence at least n+1n+1 cuts are necessary. For the construction shown alongside in the case n=7n=7, but easily generalizable to every odd nn, exactly n+1n+1 cuts are needed, which is therefore the minimum for odd nn.

Let us now analyze the case of even nn. Let R2R_{2} be the second row and C2C_{2} the second column of the grid. For every rod of length two that appears

Figure 2

in R2R_{2}, the column corresponding to the center of that rod must begin with a rod of length 1, and therefore, since the length of every column is even, it must have at least two rods of length 1.

So if we denote by ii the number of rods of length 2 that appear in R2R_{2}, there must be n2in-2i rods of length 1 in R2R_{2} and at least 2i2i rods of length 1 in the columns. In conclusion, between the second row and all the columns there are at least nn rods of length 1. Repeating the same reasoning for C2C_{2}, we find that there are at least nn rods of length 1 between C2C_{2} and all the rows. Adding these two estimates, we find that the number of rods of length 1 is at least 2nk2n-k where kk is the number of rods that have been counted twice (that is, those belonging to C2C_{2} or to R2R_{2}).

In the estimate, two rods on C2C_{2} (resp. R2R_{2}) are counted only if R2R_{2} (resp. C2C_{2}) begins with a rod of length 2 (the rods would cross!). But this cannot happen simultaneously for R2R_{2} and C2C_{2}, and therefore kk is at most 2. The minimum number of rods of length 1 is therefore 2n22n-2, which forces n1n-1 cuts. The construction alongside achieves this value for n=6n=6.

Figure 3

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from it; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.